Go to top

756 CE BY NO MEANS MILD QUAKE(S)

March 756 CE

by Jefferson Williams









Introduction & Summary

By No Means Mild Quake(s) Summary

Intensity Estimates

Intensity Estimates

Textual Evidence

Text (with hotlink) Original Language Religion Date of Composition Location Composed Notes
Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre Syriac Eastern Christian 750-775 CE Zuqnin Monastery Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre described a powerful, terrible and dreadful earthquake on Tuesday 3 March 756 CE which took place in the middle of the night in the land of the Jazira. Three villages on the Khabur collapsed, and many people perished inside them, like grapes in a wine press. Many other places were also destroyed by this earthquake. 3 March 756 CE fell on a Wednesday.
Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre, Theophanes, and the Comet of 760 CE Halley's Comet appeared in May and June of 760 CE and was both observed and recorded by Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre and Theophanes. This precise time marker can be used to anchor the year of the By No Means Mild Quake in both accounts to 756 CE.
Article by Neuhauser et al (2021) on the Comet of 760 CE Neuhauser et al (2021) identified Halley's Comet (1P/Halley) as the comet described by Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre (Chronicle of Zuqnin), Theophanes, Agapius of Menbj, Nu'aym ibn Ḥammmad, Michael the Syrian, and Chinese, Japanese and Korean sources. They performed astronomical calculations (least squares fitting of Keplerian orbital solutions) to fit "corrected" historical reports paying close attention to the month and day of astronomical observations in the sources. Despite chronological inconsistencies (year and month) among the various sources (possibly due to scribal errors) which they had to "correct", they identified the comet as 1P/Halley and obtained a precise perihelion time (760 May 19.1 ± 1.7) and an inferior conjunction between the comet and Sun (June 1.8) which is about one day different from a previously published orbit (760 May 31.9, Yeomans and Kiang, 1981). Based on their orbital model and philological arguments, Neuhauser et al (2021:7) suggest that Pseudo-Dionysius drew the comet, 3 stars (Ari), and two planets (Mars and Saturn) in his text in the early morning (before sunrise) on 25 May 760 CE.
Theophanes Greek Orthodox (Byzantium) 800-814 CE Vicinity of Constantinople Theophanes (c. 758/60-817/8) wrote that on 9 March 756 CE an earthquake that was by no means mild struck Palestine and Syria.
al-Masudi Arabic Muslim - Shi’ite mid-10th century CE Egypt ? al-Masudi wrote that Caliph al-Mahdi (r. 775-785 CE) rebuilt Jerusalem, which had been devastated by earthquakes
Description of Syria including Palestine by al-Maqdisi Arabic Muslim ca. 985 CE Jerusalem ? In "Description of Syria including Palestine", native Jerusalemite al-Maqdisi wrote that earthquakes (plural) threw down the main building of Al Aqsa Mosque, except for the Mihrab, in the days of the Abbasids (who began their rule on 25 Jan. 750 CE). The Caliph of the day financed rebuilding by having each Governor build a colonnade. The days of the Abbasides dates this to after 25 January 750 CE.
The Best Divisions in the Knowledge of the Regions by al-Maqdisi Arabic Muslim ca. 985 - 990 CE Jerusalem ? In his famous book "The Best Divisions in the Knowledge of the Regions", thought to have been written after "Description of Syria including Palestine", native Jerusalemite al-Maqdisi wrote that in the days of the ‘Abbäsides an earthquake [singular] occurred which threw down most of the main building [Al Aqsa Mosque]; all, in fact, except the part around the mihrab. The days of the Abbasides dates this to after 25 January 750 CE and since the destruction is described as total (the entire mosque except for the mihrab) and not just two walls, this appears to refer to the 2nd earthquake that struck Al-Aqsa after the Holy Desert Quake in 749 CE. This passage is almost identical to what al-Maqdisi wrote in "Description of Syria including Palestine" except that in "The Best Divisions in the Knowledge of the Regions", al-Maqdisi refers to one earthquake while in "Description of Syria including Palestine", he refers to earthquakes (plural).
Ibn al-Athir Arabic Sunni Muslim ~ 1200 - 1231 CE Mosul According to Taher (1996), Ibn al-Athir reports earthquakes in al-Massîsa (Mopsuestia) in A.H. 140 (25 May 757 - 13 May 758 CE). According to Ibn al-Athir, the surrounding wall was weakened. Reconstruction of the wall and construction of a large mosque was ordered by Caliph al-Mansûr.
Ibn al-Adim (aka Kemal ad-Din) Arabic Muslim before 1260 CE Aleppo or Cairo Ibn al-Adim (aka Kemal ad-Din) wrote that Masisah (Mopsuestia) suffered from the earthquake of the year A.H. 140 (25 May 757 - 13 May 758 CE).
Earthquake in Mopsuestia in A.H. 139 according to an unknown Muslim source Arabic Muslim Le Strange (1905:130-131), without citing a source, wrote that Massisah (Mopsuestia) had been partially destroyed by earthquake in [A.H.] 139 (5 June 756 to 24 May 757 CE).
Jamal ad Din Ahmad Arabic Muslim 1351 CE Jerusalem ? Jamal ad Din Ahmad wrote that the western and eastern parts of Al Aqsa mosque were damaged during the earthquake of A.H. 130. Caliph Al-Mansur (r. 754-775 CE ordered repairs made. The repairs were financed by stripping plates of silver and gold which had covered the Mosque's doors. A subsequent earthquake caused the repaired mosque to fall to the ground. The mosque was still in ruins when Caliph Al-Mahdi (r. 775-785 CE) ordered a rebuild but to different dimensions.
Mujir al-Din Arabic Hanbali Sunni Muslim ca. 1495 CE Jerusalem Mujir al-Din described an earthquake which damaged Al Aqsa Mosque in A.H. 130 (11 Sept. 747 - 30 Aug. 748 CE) which led to a repair during the reign of Caliph Al-Mansur (ruled 754-775 CE). A second undated earthquake is described as destroying the repaired Mosque leading to a second reconstruction to different dimensions during the reign of Caliph Al-Mahdi (ruled 775-785 CE).
Text (with hotlink) Original Language Religion Date of Composition Location Composed Notes
Chronicle of Zuqnin by Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre

Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre, Theophanes, and the Comet of 760 CE

Article by Neuhauser et al (2021) on the Comet of 760 CE

Chronicle of Theophanes

Meadows of Gold and Mines of Gems by al-Masudi

Description of Syria including Palestine by al-Maqdisi

The Best Divisions in the Knowledge of the Regions by al-Maqdisi

The Complete History by Ibn al-Athir

The Cream of the History of Aleppo by Ibn al-Adim (aka Kemal ad-Din)

Earthquake in Mopsuestia in A.H. 139 according to an unknown Muslim source

The Exciter of Desire (for Visitation of the Holy City and Syria) by Jamal ad Din Ahmad

The Glorious History of Jerusalem and Hebron by Mujir al-Din

Archaeoseismic Evidence

see Archaeoseismic Evidence for the Sabbatical Year Quakes.

Landslide Evidence

see Landslide Evidence for the Sabbatical Year Quakes.

Tsunamogenic Evidence

see Tsunamogenic Evidence for the Sabbatical Year Quakes.

Paleoseismic Evidence

see Paleoseismic Evidence for the Sabbatical Year Quakes.

Notes

Megas Chronographos

Guidoboni et al (1994:370) indicates that this earthquake is referred to in Megas Chronographos 12, but Megas Chronographos 12 refers to the Sabbatical Year Quakes - see Megas Chronographos in the Sabbatical Year Quakes.

Habura

  • Map showing location of Habura (aka Khabur) River
Guidoboni et al (1994:371) adds the following notes about Pseudo-Dionysius of Tell-Mahre's account
It has not been possible to identify the site of Habura. The only indication provided by the editor of the text of Pseudo-Dionysius of Tellmahre is a reference to the Thesaurus Syriacus (Payne Smith 1879, I, col.1172), which laconically reports: name of a city.
Habura (aka Khabur) is a tributary of the Euphrates River and is located in northern Mesopotamia (Jazira). Guidoboni et al (1994:370-371) wrote before Harrak (1999)'s translation of Pseudo-Dionysius was available so I will assume that Habura has now been identified as Khabur.

Ambraseys (2009)

AD 757 Massisa, Kafr-bia

An earthquake damaged Kafr-bia, and probably Misis. This earthquake is known only from a decree Al-Mansur issued for the rebuilding of al-Massisah following an earthquake in a.H. 140 (25 May 757 to 13 May 758). He comments that the inhabitants of the town were ‘not very numerous’. Whether this was due to the earthquake or simply reflected the fact that the town was in decline is not known.

Le Strange adds that Misis was partially destroyed by earthquake a year earlier in a.H. 139 (5 June 756 to 24 May 757); he quotes no authority (Le Strange 1905; Blochet 1895, 554 n. 3).

Notes

‘(a.H. 140) Al-Mansur decreed the rebuilding of al-Massisah in the charge of Jibra’il ibn Yahya: the girdle-wall had been weakened by the earthquake. The inhabitants of this town were not very numerous. The wall was rebuilt and called al-Ma’mura. And the clerk of the works built a great mosque. He paid the salary of 1000 workmen and allowed many of the inhabitants to set up home inside the girdle-wall.’ (MS Ar. 1683. 67r, in Blochet 1895).

References

Ambraseys, N. N. (2009). Earthquakes in the Mediterranean and Middle East: a multidisciplinary study of seismicity up to 1900.

Sbeinati et al (2005)

〈050〉 757 March 9

  • Habura: VII
  • Mesopotamia
  • Syria
  • Palestine
  • Surface faulting and liquefaction in Mesopotamia
  • Landslide at Mount Tabor
Sources
  • Theophanes: A strong earthquake in Syria and Palestine.

  • Chronicon Pseudo-Dionysus of Tell-Mahre: A big and terrible shock in the region of Mesopotamia. Near Harbura, three villages fell down.

Seismological compilations
  • Guidoboni et al. (1994): 757 March 9, Habura, Palestine, Syria and Mesopotamia I = IX. A powerful earthquake struck Syria and Palestine on 9 March 757 (Theophanes). In the year 756 on Tuesday 3 March, there was a great, violent and terrible earthquake in the land of Mesopotamia where three villages near Habura collapsed, many people there were crushed and perished (Pseudo-Dionysius).

  • Russell (1985): An earthquake by no means mild, affected Palestine and Syria on 9 March 757 (Theophanes).

References

Sbeinati, M. R., R. Darawcheh, and M. Monty (2005). "The historical earthquakes of Syria: An analysis of large and moderate earthquakes from 1365 B.C. to 1900 A.D.", Ann. Geophys. 48(3): 347-435.

Guidoboni et al (1994)

(250) 9 March 757 Habura, Mesopotamia, Palestine, Syria

sources 1

  • Theoph. 430
  • [Dion. Tellmahr.1 2.216
sources 2
  • The Great Chronogr. 12
literature
  • Payne Smith (1879)
  • Russell (1985)
  • Whitby and Whitby (1989)
catalogues
  • von Hoff (1840)
  • Mallet (1853)
  • Sieberg (1932 a)
  • Amiran (1950-51)
  • Grumel (1958)
  • Guidoboni (1989)
Theophanes records a strong earthquake in the year of the world 6248 [756-757 A.D.], during the sixteenth year of the reign of Constantine V:
In this year, a powerful earthquake struck Syria and Palestine, on 9 March.
Pseudo-Dionysius of Tellmahre reports collapses in three villages in Mesopotamia:
In the year 1067 [of the Greeks; i.e. 756 A.D.], on Tuesday 3 Adar [March], there was a great, violent and terrible earthquake at midnight in the land of Mesopotamia, and three villages near Habura collapsed. The many people who were there were crushed and perished, like grapes in the press, and many places were destroyed in the earthquake, which took place because of the great number of our sins.
It has not been possible to identify the site of Habura. The only indication provided by the editor of the text of Pseudo-Dionysius of Tellmahre is a reference to the Thesaurus Syriacus (Payne Smith 1879, I, co1.1172), which laconically reports: "name of a city". For problems of dating the sources, see Whitby and Whitby (1989, p.197).

References

Guidoboni, E., et al. (1994). Catalogue of Ancient Earthquakes in the Mediterranean Area up to the 10th Century. Rome, Istituto nazionale di geofisica.

Taher (1996)

130/747 : earthquake in Châm, in the month of Ramadan (month of May). Several seismic tremors; the most violent earthquake is in Jerusalem; the western and eastern parts of the Dome of the Rock were damaged; numerous victims including many transmitters of traditions of the Prophet (of Medinan origin). The caliph Abû Dja`far al-Mansûr removes the silver and gold plates which covered the doors of the Dome of the Rock since the caliphate of `Abd al-Malik b. Marwan. Dinars and dirhams are minted which will be used to finance the reconstructions66.

140/757 : earthquakes in al-Massîsa ; the surrounding wall is weakened. The caliph al-Mansûr decrees the reconstruction of al-Massisa under the responsibility of Djibrayl b. Yahya . The inhabitants of this town were few in number. The wall was rebuilt and the city was called al- Ma`mûra . The construction manager builds a large mosque. He paid the wages of 1000 workers67.

158/774 : second earthquake in Jerusalem under the caliphate of al-Mahdî; reconstruction of the Dome of the Rock; the architecture was modified: al-Mahdî had it rebuilt lower and wider68.

Footnotes

66 Al- Dhahabî , Târîkh al-Islâm, 5/39, 40; Al-`Ulîmî , al-Uns , 1/237, 238.

67 B. al-Athîr , al-Kâmil , 5/500. This is the ancient Greek city of Mopsuestia, cf. Honigmann , EI, t. III, p. 591-596.

68 Al-'Ulîmî, al-Uns , 1/282, 283.

References

TAHER, M.A. (1996) "Les grandes zones sismiques du monde musul-mans a travers l'histoire. I. L'Orient musulman," Annales Islamologiques 30 (1996): 79-104. - open access

Taher (1979)

140 A.H./757 AD

Al Mansûr1 decreed the reconstruction of Al-Maççiça2 under the responsibility of Djibra'il ibn Yahya. The surrounding wall had been weakened by the earthquake. The inhabitants of this town were few in number. The wall was rebuilt and called Al Ma'mura. And the head of work built a large mosque. He paid the wages of 1000 workers. It allowed many inhabitants to settle inside the enclosure.

Footnotes

1 Abu Dja'far, the 'Abbasid caliph, see Ibn al Athir, al Kamil, 5/500.

2 This is the ancient Greek city of Mopsuestia, located on the right bank of the Djaihan River. Cf. Honigmann, E.I., t.III, p.p. 591-96.

References

Taher, M.A. (1979): Corpus des texts arabes relatifs aux tremblements de terre et autres catastrophes naturelles, de la conquete arabe au XII H/XVIII JC, Ph.D. Thesis (Univ. Paris), 337 pp.

Abou Karaki (1987)

* 756 A.D. calculated date ?

  • In Syria and Palestine, a strong earthquake, (Will).

  • Between 758 and 775 AD., in Palestine and Syria, in Jerusalem, Aleppo and Antioch, destroyed buildings; strong enough

  • 765 (May 3) AD, felt in the North of Syria, damaged buildings in Jerusalem, earthquake associated with faults in the 30.8° N - 33.6° N zone, ML = 6.2 (BM1) which refers to the descriptions of (Will) above, among others.

  • 765 AD Jerusalem, the damaged AI-Aqsa Mosque (BM1)

  • 757 AD, 140 AD, the city of Misis, I = VII, (PTAH).

  • In the year 140 AD. H, the walls of the city of Misis, which were in poor state because of the earthquakes, were restored by the caliph AL-MANSOUR, and the city was renamed AL-MAMOURAH (TAHA)., NAJA: J = in the interval (23 MAY 757- 13 MAY 758), i.e. the period which corresponds to the year of restoration of the walls, 140 A.H.

French

* 756 apr. J.C date calculée ?

  • En Syrie et en Palestine, un fort séisme, (Will).

  • Entre 758 et 775 apr. J.C., en Palestine et en Syrie, à Jérusalem, Alep et Antioche, des immeubles détruits; assez fort

  • 765 (le 3 mai) apr. J.C., ressenti au Nord de la Syrie, immeubles endommagés à Jérusalem, séisme associé aux failles de la zone 30°,8 N - 33°,6 N, ML = 6,2 (BM1) qui se réfère aux descriptions de (Will) ci-dessus, entre autres.

  • 765 apr. J.C. Jérusalem, la mosquée AI-Aksa endommagée (BM1)

  • 757 apr J.C., An 140 apr.H, la ville de misis, I = VII, (PTAH).

  • En l'an 140 apr. H, les murailles de la ville de misis, qui étaient en mauvais état à cause des tremblements de terre, furent restaurées par le calife AL-MANSOUR, et la ville fut rebaptisée AL-MAMOURAH (TAHA).,

    NAJA: J = dans l'intervalle (23. MAI 757- 13. MAI 758), soit la période qui correspond à l'année de restauration des murailles, 140 apr. H.

References

Abou-Karaki, N. (1987). Synthèse et carte sismotectonique des pays de la bordure Orientale de la Méditerranée: sismicité du système de foilles du Jourdain – Mer Morte, University of Strasbourg, France. Ph.D. Diss.

Russell (1985)

The Earthquake of March 9, 757

The earthquake of 757 completes the present analysis of earthquakes in Palestine and Arabia through the mid-8th century. Theophanes wrote of this earthquake, In this year, an earthquake. by no means mild, affected Palestine and Syria on the 9th day of the month of March (1839: 662-63). The year referred to was A.M. 6248, which dates the event to March 9, 757.

Further textual documentation of this earth-quake has not been found. Cedrenus, for example. did not record any events at all between June 754 and June 759 (1839: 10-11). Even so, the temporal proximity of this earthquake to Theophanes' own lifetime (ca. 758-817), coupled with his general accuracy and consistency in documenting earlier earthquakes, suggests that sections of ancient Palestine and Syria were indeed affected by an earthquake on March 9, 757, provided that his dating is correct. Whether the Negev, the Jordan Valley, or the regions east of the rift were affected as well cannot be established from this text. No archaeological evidence has yet been correlated with this earthquake.16

Footnotes

16 In addition to destructions in 748 and 757. the region of Syria also experienced earthquakes in 713 and 717 (Theophanes 1839: 587. 614: Ambrasseys 1962: 77). The first half of the 8th century also saw the rapid decline of the Omayyad Caliphate (Hitti 1951: 527-32). The last Omayyad Caliph, Marwan II (744-750), even transferred the seat of government from Damascus to Harran (Hitti 1951: 529), probably as a result of frequent earthquake destructions and the growing discontent of his subjects. As previously observed for the disastrous earthquakes of the mid-6th century. the social and economic impact of earthquakes in the early 8th century has yet to be incorporated into our understanding of early Islamic history.

References
References

Russell, K. W. (1985). "The Earthquake Chronology of Palestine and Northwest Arabia from the 2nd through the Mid-8th Century A.D." Bulletin of the American School of Oriental Research 260: 37-59.

Russell, K. W. (1981). The earthquake chronology of ancient Palestine and Arabia from the 2nd to the 8th century A.D. Anthropology. Salt Lake City, UT, University of Utah. MS.

Cometography Comet Catalog

  • reproduced with permission from Gary Kronk (personal communication,2024)
1P/760 K1 (Halley)
  • Discovered: 760 May 15.8 (A=0.94 AU, r=0.59 AU, Elong.=35°)
  • Last seen: 760 July
  • Closest to the Earth: 760 June 2 (0.4105 AU)
  • Calculated path: ARI (Disc), PER (May 22), AUR (May 29), LYN (Jun. 3), CNC (Jun. 6), LEO (Jun. 8), VIR (Jul. 10)
The Chiu T'ang shu (945), T'ang hui yao (961), and Hsin T'ang shu (1060) provide virtually identical details of this appearance of 1P/Halley. The comet is referred to as a "broom star" when it was first seen on 760 May 16 "in the east between Lou [α, β, and γ Arietis] and Wei [35, 39, and 41 Arietis]." The date and location indicate a morning observation, implying a UT of May 15.8. The comet is described as white and about 4° long. The details acquired from the Chiu T'ang shu and Hsin T'ang shu were obtained from the astronomical chapters. It is interesting that the annals of these two texts say the comet was first seen on May 17.

The Chinese accounts say that it moved rapidly toward the northeast. It passed the Mao [the Pleiades], the Pi [α and ε Tauri], the Tsui-Hsi [γ and φ1 Orionis], the Shen [α, β, γ, δ, ζ, and κ Orionis], the Tung-Ching [γ, ε, ζ, λ, μ, ν, ξ, and 36 Geminorum), the Yu-Kuei [γ, δ, η, and θ Cancri] the Liu [δ, ε, ζ, η, θ, ρ, σ, and ω Hydrae], and Hsien-Yuan [α, γ, ε, ζ, η, κ, λ, μ, o, ρ, and 15 Leonis, and α and 38 Lyncis]. It finally moved to the west of the T'ai-wei Enclosure, 7° to the west of Yu-chih-fa [β Virginis], and was extinguished. It lasted for a total of more than 50 days.

The details of the comet's final observation are interesting to examine. First, the statement that the comet remained visible for over 50 days indicates it was still under observation following July 5. Second, although the T'ang hui yao and Hsin T'ang shu say the comet passed within 7° of β Virginis, the Chiu T'ang shu says it passed only 0.7° away. Calculations using the orbit below indicate the comet never passed closer than 3.7° from that star and that this occurred on July 13.

The Byzantine monk Theophanes the Confessor wrote Chronographia around 813 and noted that during Annus Mundi 6252 (759-60), "a very bright comet appeared for ten days in the east and another twenty-one days in the west.".

The Arabic historian Agapius of Manbij (10th century) reported, "In this year the star with a tail appeared, and it was in Aries before the Sun, and the Sun was in Leo. It proceeded until it was under the rays of the sun, then went behind it and stayed 40 days." David Cook (1998) has suggested the observation was actually made by Theophilus of Edessa.

The first person to suggest that this comet was 1P/Halley was P. A. E. Laugier (1846). Although he did not compute an orbit, he said the orbit of that comet could fit the available Chinese observations if the perihelion date was estimated as 760 June 11. J. R. Hind (1850) investigated this apparition and agreed with Laugier's conclusion, right down to the date of perihelion. He said, "The return of the comet in 760 appears to me little short of a certainty." P. H. Cowell and A. C. D. Crommelin (1908) were the first to investigate the long-term orbital motion of 1P/Halley and concluded the perihelion date was 760 June 15. The modern orbital investigations of D. K. Yeomans and T. Kiang (1981), Werner Landgraf (1986), and G. Sitarski (1988) have included the effects of nongravitational forces and have almost unanimously determined the perihelion date as 760 May 20. Calculations using the Yeomans-Kiang orbit below indicate the comet reached at a minimum solar elongation of 2° on April 3 and a maximum solar elongation of 35° on May 17. On June 1 the comet reached another minimum solar elongation (18°), and on June 2, it attained its most northerly declination of +41° (apparent). It reached a maximum solar elongation of 54° on June 22.

T ω Ω (2000.0) i q e
760 May 20.671 (UT) 99.997 44.687 163.443 0.58184 0.96785
  • ABSOLUTE MAGNITUDE: H10=2 (Vsekhsvyatskij, 1964), 4.0 (Kronk)
  • FULL MOON: April 5, May 4, June 3, July 3
Sources

Chronographia (813), p. 597

Chin Tang situ (945), p. 171

T'ang hui yao (961), p. 171

Agapius of Manbij (10th century), p. 542

Hsin T'ang situ (1060), p. 171

Synopsis Istorion (1100), p. 464

A. G. Pingre (1783), pp. 336-7, 610-11

CR, 15 (1842 Nov. 21), pp. 952-3

CR, 23 (1846), pp. 186-7

MNRAS, 10 (1850 Jan. 11), p. 56

PMJS (3rd Series), 36 (1850 Jun.), pp. 471, 474

J. Williams (1871), p. 44

G. F. Chambers (1889), pp. 512-13

MNRAS, 68 (May 1908), pp. 510-14

PA, 42 (1934 Apr.), p. 196

Ho Peng Yoke (1962), p. 171

S. K. Vsekhsvyatskij (1964), p. 48

MRAS, 76 (1972), pp. 35, 53

R. R. Newton (1972), p. 683

CAA, 3 (1979), p. 122

D. K. Yeomans and T. Kiang (1981), p. 643

J. L. Brady (1982), p. 210

IBIS, 38 (1985), pp. 205-6

W. Landgraf (1986), p. 258

G. Sitarski (1988), p. 263

personal correspondence from David Cook (1998).

References

Kronk, Gary W. (1999) Cometography A Catalog of Comets Vol. 1 Ancient-1799: A Catalog of Comets 1 Cambridge University Press - not open access - Cambridge University Press

References

References