Transliterated Name | Language | Name |
---|---|---|
Tverya | Hebrew | טיבריות |
Ṭabariyyā | Arabic | طبريا |
Rakkath | Biblical Hebrew (Joshua 19:35) | רקבת |
Chamath | Ancient Israelite (Jewish tradition) | חמת |
Tiberiás | Ancient Greek | Τιβεριάς |
Tiveriáda | Modern Greek | Τιβεριάδα |
Tiberiás | Latin | Tiberiás |
Tiberias | English | Tiberias |
Chronology is well established as damage and destruction in Tiberias due to the 1837 CE Safed Quake was described and recorded by several contemporaneous sources based on first hand accounts - some of which are listed below:
Source | Report | Notes |
---|---|---|
Article in the Missionary Herald by William McClure Thomson | The first day of this year (1837 CE) will be long remembered as the anniversary of one of the most violent and destructive earthquakes which this country has ever experienced |
|
The Times (of London) | A LIST OF TOWNS ETC., DESTROYED OR INJURED IN SYRIA BY THE EARTHQUAKE ON THE 1st OF JANUARY |
Effect | Location | Image(s) | Description |
---|---|---|---|
Damaged and Tilted Walls | Citadel Walls (P1) and turrets (T4-T7)
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2b
the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 19
. 1839a: Damage to the citadel and walls. Note the completeness of the Seraiah (P2) and the presence of the minaret of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 25
1841: Ruins of Tiberias. The citadel (P1) is depicted as slightly damaged (Munk, 1845). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 26
1842a: Tiberias and its citadel in a drawing drawn from the north (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Note the similarity of T4 and T5 to their recent state (upper left corner) and the accuracy of the hatch (red square) as drawn by Bartlett Zohar (2017)
Fig. 30
1842e: sketch of Tiberias from the west. Large breaches appear in the western and southern walls of the city (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017) |
|
Sheared Wall | Southern turret in Southern Wall
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2f
one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Sheared turret in Tiberias' southern Wall
Photo by Jefferson Williams on 11 June 2023
Fig. 38
1863: Tiberias from the western road leading to the main gate. Note the possible identification of turret T17 (Unknown, 1867). In my opinion the drawing was copied from Munk (1845). Zohar (2017) |
|
Dome collapse | al-Zaydani Mosque (M1)
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2a
al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Fig. 4
1814: al-Zaydani mosque drawn from close range within the city itself (Light, 1818). Note the relatively large dome also present in other pre-1837 drawings (e.g., Buckingham, 1822; Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837; Wilson, 1823). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 19
. 1839a: Damage to the citadel and walls. Note the completeness of the Seraiah (P2) and the presence of the minaret of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 22
1839d: The citadel (P1) is depicted partially ruined; the Seraiah (P2); the walls that are partially ruined, al-Zaydani mosque without a dome (Roberts, 1842-1849). Note turret T21 leaning towards the east and its lower supporting belt (noted by red arrow). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 25
1841: Ruins of Tiberias. The citadel (P1) is depicted as slightly damaged (Munk, 1845). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 32
1848: Tiberias from the north, probably drawn somewhere on the hill of the citadel (Lynch, 1849). Prominent features:
Zohar (2017)
Fig. 33
1849: the road from Safed leading to Tiberias, the citadel and the walls (Spencer, 1850). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 39
c.1870: a photograph probably taken from the hill of the citadel (Bonfils, 1878?). The northern region was not populated. No minaret of al-Bahri mosque, no dome to al-Zaydani. Zohar (2017) |
|
Minaret Collapse | al-Bahri Mosque (M2)
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2c
al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 39
c.1870: a photograph probably taken from the hill of the citadel (Bonfils, 1878?). The northern region was not populated. No minaret of al-Bahri mosque, no dome to al-Zaydani. Zohar (2017) |
|
Vault Destruction - completely or badly destroyed | Vaulted Bazaar (P7)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2d
remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow). Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
|
Damaged Arches | Vaulted Arcs (P8)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 45
1898-1914: (ACPD, 1898-1914b) Zohar (2017) |
|
Collapsed Walls | dwellings
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
|
Damaged Walls | City Walls (W1-21)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
1828: Tiberias from the south in the book of Leon de Laborde. The latter visited Palestine in 1828 but his book on Syria, Lebanon and Palestine was published only in 1837. The book contains also other artist’s drawings. This drawing was drawn by Marilhat and considered realistic. For example, the number of turrets and location of the citadel are accurate in light of our current knowledge of the Tiberias morphology (Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017)
Fig. 15
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the south (Leitch & Foster, 1855). In my opinion, this is probably a copy of the sketch after Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 17
Before 1837: The drawing portrays Tiberias prior to the earthquake but the date of painting is unresolved. It appears only in the 5th edition of Lindsay (1858). Lindsay visited Palestine twice and only after the earthquake (1837 and 1847) and thus, in my opinion, the drawing is a copy of a previous one, perhaps of Lehoux (de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
|
Damaged Walls | Turrets (T1-20)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
|
Tilted Wall | Leaning Turret (T21)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 31
1842f: the leaning turret (T21) and the citadel (P1) (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 22
1839d: The citadel (P1) is depicted partially ruined; the Seraiah (P2); the walls that are partially ruined, al-Zaydani mosque without a dome (Roberts, 1842-1849). Note turret T21 leaning towards the east and its lower supporting belt (noted by red arrow). Zohar (2017) |
|
Collapsed Wall | Main Gate (G1)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 11
1835: The town from the north. Note the turrets and the two minarets of al-Zaydani and al-Bahri mosques (Harding, 1835). The drawing was probably copied from the drawing of Marilhat (in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 18
1837: Tiberias from the north, after the voyage of Bernatz and Schubert (Bernatz & Schubert, 1839). The drawing seems to be realistic as prominent features (e.g., W8 and T10) are depicted in similar shape and size as they are today. JW: Gate G1 is 'missing' Zohar (2017) |
|
Damaged Walls | Southern Gate (G2)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
1828: Tiberias from the south in the book of Leon de Laborde. The latter visited Palestine in 1828 but his book on Syria, Lebanon and Palestine was published only in 1837. The book contains also other artist’s drawings. This drawing was drawn by Marilhat and considered realistic. For example, the number of turrets and location of the citadel are accurate in light of our current knowledge of the Tiberias morphology (Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017) |
|
Collapsed Walls | Walls of the Jewish Quarter (JW1-2)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
|
Collapsed Walls | Gate of the Jewish Quarter (JG1)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
|
Collapsed Walls | Etz-Ha'yim ('Sephardim') Synagogue (S1)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2e
Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
|
Collapsed Walls | Hasidim' Synagogue (S2)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
|
Casualties | Tiberias
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
|
Image | Figure | Description | Source |
---|---|---|---|
Fig. 2a
al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2a | al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2b
the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2b | the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2c
al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2c | al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2d
remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow). Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2d | remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow) |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2e
Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2e | Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2f
one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2f | one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent |
Zohar (2017) |
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
Zohar (2017) |
Table 1 | Damage Table | Zohar (2017) |
Table 2
The number of damaged dwellings and structures in the Tiberias quarters classified by an estimated damage degree. Note that the maximal degree of damage in the Jewish quarter is less than that of the Muslim and Christian quarters. See also Figure 8. Zohar (2017) |
Table 2 | Damage in the Quarters | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 6 | Tiberias before the 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
3D view of Tiberias
Zohar (2017) |
Figure 7 | 3D reconstruction of Tiberias before and after the 1837 CE Safed Quake |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 8
The spread of the earthquake damage that resulted in Tiberias by comparing the two HGIS models of before and after the earthquake (Figure 7). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 8 | Map of damage in Tiberias due to 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Effect | Location | Image(s) | Description | Intensity |
---|---|---|---|---|
Damaged and Tilted Walls | Citadel Walls (P1) and turrets (T4-T7)
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2b
the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 19
. 1839a: Damage to the citadel and walls. Note the completeness of the Seraiah (P2) and the presence of the minaret of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 25
1841: Ruins of Tiberias. The citadel (P1) is depicted as slightly damaged (Munk, 1845). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 26
1842a: Tiberias and its citadel in a drawing drawn from the north (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Note the similarity of T4 and T5 to their recent state (upper left corner) and the accuracy of the hatch (red square) as drawn by Bartlett Zohar (2017)
Fig. 30
1842e: sketch of Tiberias from the west. Large breaches appear in the western and southern walls of the city (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017) |
|
VII + |
Sheared Wall | Southern turret in Southern Wall
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2f
one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Sheared turret in Tiberias' southern Wall
Photo by Jefferson Williams on 11 June 2023
Fig. 38
1863: Tiberias from the western road leading to the main gate. Note the possible identification of turret T17 (Unknown, 1867). In my opinion the drawing was copied from Munk (1845). Zohar (2017) |
VIII + | |
Dome collapse | al-Zaydani Mosque (M1)
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2a
al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Fig. 4
1814: al-Zaydani mosque drawn from close range within the city itself (Light, 1818). Note the relatively large dome also present in other pre-1837 drawings (e.g., Buckingham, 1822; Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837; Wilson, 1823). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 19
. 1839a: Damage to the citadel and walls. Note the completeness of the Seraiah (P2) and the presence of the minaret of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 22
1839d: The citadel (P1) is depicted partially ruined; the Seraiah (P2); the walls that are partially ruined, al-Zaydani mosque without a dome (Roberts, 1842-1849). Note turret T21 leaning towards the east and its lower supporting belt (noted by red arrow). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 25
1841: Ruins of Tiberias. The citadel (P1) is depicted as slightly damaged (Munk, 1845). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 32
1848: Tiberias from the north, probably drawn somewhere on the hill of the citadel (Lynch, 1849). Prominent features:
Zohar (2017)
Fig. 33
1849: the road from Safed leading to Tiberias, the citadel and the walls (Spencer, 1850). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 39
c.1870: a photograph probably taken from the hill of the citadel (Bonfils, 1878?). The northern region was not populated. No minaret of al-Bahri mosque, no dome to al-Zaydani. Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + |
Minaret Collapse | al-Bahri Mosque (M2)
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2c
al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 39
c.1870: a photograph probably taken from the hill of the citadel (Bonfils, 1878?). The northern region was not populated. No minaret of al-Bahri mosque, no dome to al-Zaydani. Zohar (2017) |
|
VI-VII + |
Vault Destruction - completely or badly destroyed | Vaulted Bazaar (P7)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 2d
remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow). Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + |
Damaged Arches | Vaulted Arcs (P8)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017)
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
|
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 45
1898-1914: (ACPD, 1898-1914b) Zohar (2017) |
|
VI + |
Collapsed Walls | dwellings
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + |
Damaged Walls | City Walls (W1-21)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
1828: Tiberias from the south in the book of Leon de Laborde. The latter visited Palestine in 1828 but his book on Syria, Lebanon and Palestine was published only in 1837. The book contains also other artist’s drawings. This drawing was drawn by Marilhat and considered realistic. For example, the number of turrets and location of the citadel are accurate in light of our current knowledge of the Tiberias morphology (Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017)
Fig. 15
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the south (Leitch & Foster, 1855). In my opinion, this is probably a copy of the sketch after Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 17
Before 1837: The drawing portrays Tiberias prior to the earthquake but the date of painting is unresolved. It appears only in the 5th edition of Lindsay (1858). Lindsay visited Palestine twice and only after the earthquake (1837 and 1847) and thus, in my opinion, the drawing is a copy of a previous one, perhaps of Lehoux (de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017)
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
|
VII-VIII + |
Damaged Walls | Turrets (T1-20)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
VII + | |
Tilted Wall | Leaning Turret (T21)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 31
1842f: the leaning turret (T21) and the citadel (P1) (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 22
1839d: The citadel (P1) is depicted partially ruined; the Seraiah (P2); the walls that are partially ruined, al-Zaydani mosque without a dome (Roberts, 1842-1849). Note turret T21 leaning towards the east and its lower supporting belt (noted by red arrow). Zohar (2017) |
|
VI + |
Collapsed Wall | Main Gate (G1)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 11
1835: The town from the north. Note the turrets and the two minarets of al-Zaydani and al-Bahri mosques (Harding, 1835). The drawing was probably copied from the drawing of Marilhat (in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017)
Fig. 18
1837: Tiberias from the north, after the voyage of Bernatz and Schubert (Bernatz & Schubert, 1839). The drawing seems to be realistic as prominent features (e.g., W8 and T10) are depicted in similar shape and size as they are today. JW: Gate G1 is 'missing' Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + |
Damaged Walls | Southern Gate (G2)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
1828: Tiberias from the south in the book of Leon de Laborde. The latter visited Palestine in 1828 but his book on Syria, Lebanon and Palestine was published only in 1837. The book contains also other artist’s drawings. This drawing was drawn by Marilhat and considered realistic. For example, the number of turrets and location of the citadel are accurate in light of our current knowledge of the Tiberias morphology (Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017) |
|
VII + |
Collapsed Walls | Walls of the Jewish Quarter (JW1-2)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + | |
Collapsed Walls | Gate of the Jewish Quarter (JG1)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + | |
Collapsed Walls | Etz-Ha'yim ('Sephardim') Synagogue (S1)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2e
Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + |
Collapsed Walls | Hasidim' Synagogue (S2)
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
|
VIII + |
Image | Figure | Description | Source |
---|---|---|---|
Fig. 1a
Damage distribution in Ottoman Palestine and its close surroundings caused by the 1837 earthquake (Ambraseys 1997, 2009) and classified by the degree of severity (Zohar et al. 2013); Zohar (2017) |
Figure 1a | Damage Distribution from the 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 1b | Satellite View of the Old City of Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2a
al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2a | al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2b
the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2b | the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2c
al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2c | al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2d
remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow). Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2d | remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow) |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2e
Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2e | Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2f
one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2f | one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 3
Visual sources used for reconstructing the landscape. On the right: location and azimuth (angle towards Tiberias from the given point) of the visual sources, i.e., air photos, drawings and photographs (Appendix 1). The map also presents topographic contours. On the left:
Zohar (2017) |
Figure 3 | Visual sources used for reconstructing the landscape | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 5
Detecting Tiberias features in visual sources (example, northern view)
Note the simultaneous detection of the depicted features in Figure C and in the model (Figure D). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 5 | Feature Detection | Zohar (2017) |
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
Zohar (2017) |
Table 1 | Damage Table | Zohar (2017) |
Table 2
The number of damaged dwellings and structures in the Tiberias quarters classified by an estimated damage degree. Note that the maximal degree of damage in the Jewish quarter is less than that of the Muslim and Christian quarters. See also Figure 8. Zohar (2017) |
Table 2 | Damage in the Quarters | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 6 | Tiberias before the 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
3D view of Tiberias
Prominent features (Table 1) are labelled in black. Note that the majority of Tiberias is located on basalt rocks and note the extensive damage along the fault that crosses the western walls. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 7 | 3D reconstruction of Tiberias before and after the 1837 CE Safed Quake |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 8
The spread of the earthquake damage that resulted in Tiberias by comparing the two HGIS models of before and after the earthquake (Figure 7). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 8 | Map of damage in Tiberias due to 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Image | Figure | Description | Source |
---|---|---|---|
Fig. 1a
Damage distribution in Ottoman Palestine and its close surroundings caused by the 1837 earthquake (Ambraseys 1997, 2009) and classified by the degree of severity (Zohar et al. 2013); Zohar (2017) |
Figure 1a | Damage Distribution from the 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 1b
General overview of the old city of Tiberias. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 1b | Satellite View of the Old City of Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2a
al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2a | al-Zaydani Mosque in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2b
the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2b | the Citadel in Tiberias where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2c
al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2c | al-Bahri Mosque in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2d
remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow). Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2d | remains of the massive vaults in southern Tiberias (noted by red arrow) |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2e
Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2e | Etz-Hay’im Synagogue in Tiberias | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2f
one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls. Photograph: Motti Zohar, 2015 Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2f | one of the southern damaged turrets in Tiberias’s walls where 1837 earthquake damage is apparent |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 3
Visual sources used for reconstructing the landscape. On the right: location and azimuth (angle towards Tiberias from the given point) of the visual sources, i.e., air photos, drawings and photographs (Appendix 1). The map also presents topographic contours. On the left:
Zohar (2017) |
Figure 3 | Visual sources used for reconstructing the landscape | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 5
Detecting Tiberias features in visual sources (example, northern view)
Note the simultaneous detection of the depicted features in Figure C and in the model (Figure D). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 5 | Feature Detection | Zohar (2017) |
Table 1
Localities in Tiberias reported to be damaged during the 1837 earthquake.
Zohar (2017) |
Table 1 | Damage Table | Zohar (2017) |
Table 2
The number of damaged dwellings and structures in the Tiberias quarters classified by an estimated damage degree. Note that the maximal degree of damage in the Jewish quarter is less than that of the Muslim and Christian quarters. See also Figure 8. Zohar (2017) |
Table 2 | Damage in the Quarters | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 6
Tiberias and its major features prior to the 1837 earthquake (for notations see Table 1). The city interior was compiled using pre-1837 drawings (Appendix 1), maps of Palestine (1938), PEF (1918), Burckhardt (1822) and historical accounts (Mariti 1791, Clarke 1810–1823, Light 1818, Turner 1820, Buckingham 1822, Richardson 1822, Scholz 1822, Wilson 1823, Carne 1826, Jowett 1826, Maden 1829, Madox 1834, Horne 1836, Stephens 1839, Kinglake 1848). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 6 | Tiberias before the 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
3D view of Tiberias
Prominent features (Table 1) are labelled in black. Note that the majority of Tiberias is located on basalt rocks and note the extensive damage along the fault that crosses the western walls. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 7 | 3D reconstruction of Tiberias before and after the 1837 CE Safed Quake |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 8
The spread of the earthquake damage that resulted in Tiberias by comparing the two HGIS models of before and after the earthquake (Figure 7). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 8 | Map of damage in Tiberias due to 1837 CE Safed Quake | Zohar (2017) |
Image | Figure | Description | Source |
---|---|---|---|
Fig. 1
1681: Tiberias walls before the reconstruction of Dahir al-Umar. Note the church of St. Peter (C1) and the probable location of the Jewish quarter (de-Bruyn, 1702) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 1 | Painting of Tiberias in 1681 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2
1799: Tiberias at the end of the 18th century as mapped by Jacotin for military purposes. Note the roads leading to the city and the fact that there is no road entering Tiberias from the north. See also the location of the main (G1) and southern (G2) gates (Jacotin, 1799) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2 | Map of Tiberias in 1799 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 3
1810-12: Tiberias at the beginning of the 19th century (in brackets - identification according to Table 3)
(Burckhardt, 1822) Note that Burckhardt confuses the number of turrets (counts 25 instead of 21) and neglects a northern turret (T1) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 3 | Map of Tiberias in 1810-1812 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 4
1814: al-Zaydani mosque drawn from close range within the city itself (Light, 1818). Note the relatively large dome also present in other pre-1837 drawings (e.g., Buckingham, 1822; Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837; Wilson, 1823). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 4 | al-Zaydani Mosque in 1814 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 5
1816: Buckingham draws the citadel (P1) as having only one turret but the other turrets (e.g., T10, T16, T20, T21) seems to be drawn correctly. Note the al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Buckingham, 1822). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 5 | Painting of Tiberias in 1816 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 6
1822: al-Zaydani (M1) and al-Bahri (M2) mosques. The minaret of al-Zaydani is portrayed relatively high above the dome. Note the possible identification of St. Peter church (C1) (Wilson, 1823). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 6 | Painting of Tiberias in 1822 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
1828: Tiberias from the south in the book of Leon de Laborde. The latter visited Palestine in 1828 but his book on Syria, Lebanon and Palestine was published only in 1837. The book contains also other artist’s drawings. This drawing was drawn by Marilhat and considered realistic. For example, the number of turrets and location of the citadel are accurate in light of our current knowledge of the Tiberias morphology (Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 7 | Painting of Tiberias in 1828 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 8
1828: Tiberias from the west (de Laborde, 1837). Note the accuracy in counting the turrets: six (T16-T21) at the south of the city and six (T10‐T15) at its western side. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 8 | Painting of Tiberias in 1828 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 9
1832: The city drawn from the north (Russell, 1832). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 9 | Painting of Tiberias in 1832 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 10
1833: Sketch of Tiberias drawn from northeast of the city. Despite the exaggerated topography one can detect prominent features, e.g., the western main gate (G1) and the surrounding turrets. Note that two minarets appear, probably of the al-Zaydani (M1) and al-Bahri (M2) mosques (Skinner, 1836). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 10 | Painting of Tiberias in 1833 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 11
1835: The town from the north. Note the turrets and the two minarets of al-Zaydani and al-Bahri mosques (Harding, 1835). The drawing was probably copied from the drawing of Marilhat (in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 11 | Painting of Tiberias in 1835 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 12
Prior to 1837 (1835?): Tiberias and the Sea of Galilee. No significant identification of features (Thomas Allom in Carne, 1838). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 12 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE (1835?) |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 13
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the south (Lindsay, 1858). The drawing portrays Tiberias prior to the earthquake but the date is unresolved. The drawing appears only in the 5th edition of the book of Lord Lindsay published in 1858. However, Lindsay visited Palestine only after the earthquake, in 1837 and 1847. Thus, in my opinion, it was copied from a previous drawing, perhaps from Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 13 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 14
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the north (Leitch & Foster, 1855). In my opinion, this is probably a copy of the sketch after Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 14 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 15
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the south (Leitch & Foster, 1855). In my opinion, this is probably a copy of the sketch after Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 15 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 16 | Painting of Tiberias in 1837 CE after the earthquake compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 17
Before 1837: The drawing portrays Tiberias prior to the earthquake but the date of painting is unresolved. It appears only in the 5th edition of Lindsay (1858). Lindsay visited Palestine twice and only after the earthquake (1837 and 1847) and thus, in my opinion, the drawing is a copy of a previous one, perhaps of Lehoux (de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 17 | Painting of Tiberias before 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 18
1837: Tiberias from the north, after the voyage of Bernatz and Schubert (Bernatz & Schubert, 1839). The drawing seems to be realistic as prominent features (e.g., W8 and T10) are depicted in similar shape and size as they are today. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 18 | Painting of Tiberias in 1837 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 19
. 1839a: Damage to the citadel and walls. Note the completeness of the Seraiah (P2) and the presence of the minaret of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 19 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 20 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 21
1839c: The western walls are drawn as partially ruined (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 21 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 22
1839d: The citadel (P1) is depicted partially ruined; the Seraiah (P2); the walls that are partially ruined, al-Zaydani mosque without a dome (Roberts, 1842-1849). Note turret T21 leaning towards the east and its lower supporting belt (noted by red arrow). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 22 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 23
1840: Tiberias from the south, probably from a spot close to the thermal baths. The depiction of the city is vague but one can detect the citadel (P1) drawn as slightly damaged and few turrets (T1, T2 and T21) (Egerton, 1841) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 23 | Painting of Tiberias in 1840 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 24
1841: Tiberias from the south by Barnes (1841). Although few features are depicted differently, it seems that this drawing was copied from the drawing of Egerton (1841). Yet, note that in this drawing the lean of T1 and T2 is clearly seen. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 24 | Painting of Tiberias in 1841 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 25
1841: Ruins of Tiberias. The citadel (P1) is depicted as slightly damaged (Munk, 1845). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 25 | Painting of Tiberias in 1841 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 26
1842a: Tiberias and its citadel in a drawing drawn from the north (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Note the similarity of T4 and T5 to their recent state (upper left corner) and the accuracy of the hatch (red square) as drawn by Bartlett Zohar (2017) |
Figure 26 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 27
1842b: Tiberias drawn from the thermal baths. Note the four turrets that erect above the others (probably ruined) and remains of damaged walls (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 27 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 28
1842c: Tiberias from the west. Several turrets seem to be relatively higher than the others and in the western walls large breaches appear (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 28 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 29
1842d: Tiberias view drawn from the citadel of Safed. Note the citadel of Tiberias (P1) (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 29 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 30
1842e: sketch of Tiberias from the west. Large breaches appear in the western and southern walls of the city (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 30 | Sketch of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 31
1842f: the leaning turret (T21) and the citadel (P1) (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 31 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 32
1848: Tiberias from the north, probably drawn somewhere on the hill of the citadel (Lynch, 1849). Prominent features:
Zohar (2017) |
Figure 32 | Drawing of Tiberias in 1848 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 33
1849: the road from Safed leading to Tiberias, the citadel and the walls (Spencer, 1850). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 33 | Painting of Tiberias in 1849 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 34
1851: The citadel of Tiberias from the north (Schulz, 1852). One can observe a trail leading from the shore of the lake of Galilee into the city. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 34 | Painting of Tiberias in 1851 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 35 | Painting of Tiberias in 1851-52 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 36
1856 (?): the region surrounding the Sea of Galilee (Robinson & Smith, 1856) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 36 | Map of the region in 1856 (?) CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 37
1860: Tiberias from the south (Strauss, 1861). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 37 | Painting of Tiberias in 1860 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 38
1863: Tiberias from the western road leading to the main gate. Note the possible identification of turret T17 (Unknown, 1867). In my opinion the drawing was copied from Munk (1845). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 38 | Drawing of Tiberias in 1863 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 39
c.1870: a photograph probably taken from the hill of the citadel (Bonfils, 1878?). The northern region was not populated. No minaret of al-Bahri mosque, no dome to al-Zaydani. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 39 | Photo of Tiberias c.1870 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 40
1880: Map of the Sea of Galilee and Tiberias (Lvov, 1880). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 40 | Map of the Sea of Galilee and Tiberias in 1681 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 41
1880: Tiberias and its close vicinity (PEF, 1918). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 41 | Map of Tiberias and vicinity 1880 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 42
1885 (?): Tiberias towards the end of the 19th century (Frei, 1885). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 42 | Plan of Tiberias in 1885 (?) | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 43
1900-1920: (ACPD, 1900‐1920). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 43 | Aerial Photo of of Tiberias 1900-1920 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 44
1898-1914: (ACPD, 1898-1914a): large breaches in the western walls, similar to the drawings of Lehoux 1837 (item 16). Note the new dome of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) and that there is no minaret to al-Bahri mosque. Turrets T16-T17 marks the transitions between unharmed and harmed part of the southern wall. A southern road entering the city, probably an expansion of a large breach in the walls, is clearly observed. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 44 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1914 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 45
1898-1914: (ACPD, 1898-1914b) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 45 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1914 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 46
1898-1946: (ACPD, 1898-1946b) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 46 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1946 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 47
1898-1946: (ACPD, 1898-1946a) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 47 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1946 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 48
. 1931: air photo of Tiberias taken from north of the city (ACPD, 1931a). The W2 part of the walls seems to be compatible with the drawing of Bartlett (item 26) and strengthens the claim that the northern parts of the walls were not affected significantly. Other breaches in the northern walls (E.g., the breach of the northern road to the city) might have been extended only after the event. The red dotted line assists in geo-tagging the location of the photographing camera/airplane (Fig. 3) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 48 | Aerial Photo of Tiberias 1931 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 49
1931: air photo of Tiberias taken south of the city (ACPD, 1931b). Note that some dwellings at the beginning of the 20th century were built on top of existing turrets (e.g., T19 and T20). The red dotted line assists in geo-tagging the location of the photographing camera/airplane (Fig. 3) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 49 | Aerial Photo of Tiberias 1931 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 50
1938: British map of Survey of Palestine, 1938 (Survey of Palestine, 1938) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 50 | Map of Tiberias in 1938 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Image | Figure | Description | Source |
---|---|---|---|
Fig. 1
1681: Tiberias walls before the reconstruction of Dahir al-Umar. Note the church of St. Peter (C1) and the probable location of the Jewish quarter (de-Bruyn, 1702) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 1 | Painting of Tiberias in 1681 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 2
1799: Tiberias at the end of the 18th century as mapped by Jacotin for military purposes. Note the roads leading to the city and the fact that there is no road entering Tiberias from the north. See also the location of the main (G1) and southern (G2) gates (Jacotin, 1799) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 2 | Map of Tiberias in 1799 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 3
1810-12: Tiberias at the beginning of the 19th century (in brackets - identification according to Table 3)
(Burckhardt, 1822) Note that Burckhardt confuses the number of turrets (counts 25 instead of 21) and neglects a northern turret (T1) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 3 | Map of Tiberias in 1810-1812 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 4
1814: al-Zaydani mosque drawn from close range within the city itself (Light, 1818). Note the relatively large dome also present in other pre-1837 drawings (e.g., Buckingham, 1822; Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837; Wilson, 1823). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 4 | al-Zaydani Mosque in 1814 CE compared to ~2016 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 5
1816: Buckingham draws the citadel (P1) as having only one turret but the other turrets (e.g., T10, T16, T20, T21) seems to be drawn correctly. Note the al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Buckingham, 1822). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 5 | Painting of Tiberias in 1816 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 6
1822: al-Zaydani (M1) and al-Bahri (M2) mosques. The minaret of al-Zaydani is portrayed relatively high above the dome. Note the possible identification of St. Peter church (C1) (Wilson, 1823). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 6 | Painting of Tiberias in 1822 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 7
1828: Tiberias from the south in the book of Leon de Laborde. The latter visited Palestine in 1828 but his book on Syria, Lebanon and Palestine was published only in 1837. The book contains also other artist’s drawings. This drawing was drawn by Marilhat and considered realistic. For example, the number of turrets and location of the citadel are accurate in light of our current knowledge of the Tiberias morphology (Marilhat in de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 7 | Painting of Tiberias in 1828 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 8
1828: Tiberias from the west (de Laborde, 1837). Note the accuracy in counting the turrets: six (T16-T21) at the south of the city and six (T10‐T15) at its western side. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 8 | Painting of Tiberias in 1828 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 9
1832: The city drawn from the north (Russell, 1832). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 9 | Painting of Tiberias in 1832 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 10
1833: Sketch of Tiberias drawn from northeast of the city. Despite the exaggerated topography one can detect prominent features, e.g., the western main gate (G1) and the surrounding turrets. Note that two minarets appear, probably of the al-Zaydani (M1) and al-Bahri (M2) mosques (Skinner, 1836). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 10 | Painting of Tiberias in 1833 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 11
1835: The town from the north. Note the turrets and the two minarets of al-Zaydani and al-Bahri mosques (Harding, 1835). The drawing was probably copied from the drawing of Marilhat (in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 11 | Painting of Tiberias in 1835 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 12
Prior to 1837 (1835?): Tiberias and the Sea of Galilee. No significant identification of features (Thomas Allom in Carne, 1838). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 12 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE (1835?) |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 13
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the south (Lindsay, 1858). The drawing portrays Tiberias prior to the earthquake but the date is unresolved. The drawing appears only in the 5th edition of the book of Lord Lindsay published in 1858. However, Lindsay visited Palestine only after the earthquake, in 1837 and 1847. Thus, in my opinion, it was copied from a previous drawing, perhaps from Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 13 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 14
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the north (Leitch & Foster, 1855). In my opinion, this is probably a copy of the sketch after Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 14 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 15
Prior to 1837: Tiberias from the south (Leitch & Foster, 1855). In my opinion, this is probably a copy of the sketch after Marilhat (de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 15 | Painting of Tiberias Prior to 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 16
1837: Tiberias after the earthquake drawn from the south. Note the damage to the citadel (P1), to the walls and to its turrets (T4‐T17). The Jewish quarter is depicted as partially destroyed while in the Muslim and Christian quarters there are hardly any standing dwellings. The drawing seems to be realistic: parts of the walls (e.g., W7b, W8a, and W16) and turrets (e.g., T8, T10 and T16) that were drawn as not destroyed still exist till today (Lehoux in de Laborde, 1837). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 16 | Painting of Tiberias in 1837 CE after the earthquake compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 17
Before 1837: The drawing portrays Tiberias prior to the earthquake but the date of painting is unresolved. It appears only in the 5th edition of Lindsay (1858). Lindsay visited Palestine twice and only after the earthquake (1837 and 1847) and thus, in my opinion, the drawing is a copy of a previous one, perhaps of Lehoux (de Laborde, 1837) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 17 | Painting of Tiberias before 1837 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 18
1837: Tiberias from the north, after the voyage of Bernatz and Schubert (Bernatz & Schubert, 1839). The drawing seems to be realistic as prominent features (e.g., W8 and T10) are depicted in similar shape and size as they are today. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 18 | Painting of Tiberias in 1837 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 19
. 1839a: Damage to the citadel and walls. Note the completeness of the Seraiah (P2) and the presence of the minaret of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 19 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 20
1839b: Tiberias from the south. Note the arched vaults (P8), al-Zaydani mosque and minaret but no dome, the ruined citadel (P1), the Seraiah (P2), a Synagogue (Etz Hayim?, S1), turret T1 in the water, and St. Peter church (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 20 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 21
1839c: The western walls are drawn as partially ruined (Roberts, 1842-1849). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 21 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 22
1839d: The citadel (P1) is depicted partially ruined; the Seraiah (P2); the walls that are partially ruined, al-Zaydani mosque without a dome (Roberts, 1842-1849). Note turret T21 leaning towards the east and its lower supporting belt (noted by red arrow). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 22 | Painting of Tiberias in 1839 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 23
1840: Tiberias from the south, probably from a spot close to the thermal baths. The depiction of the city is vague but one can detect the citadel (P1) drawn as slightly damaged and few turrets (T1, T2 and T21) (Egerton, 1841) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 23 | Painting of Tiberias in 1840 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 24
1841: Tiberias from the south by Barnes (1841). Although few features are depicted differently, it seems that this drawing was copied from the drawing of Egerton (1841). Yet, note that in this drawing the lean of T1 and T2 is clearly seen. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 24 | Painting of Tiberias in 1841 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 25
1841: Ruins of Tiberias. The citadel (P1) is depicted as slightly damaged (Munk, 1845). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 25 | Painting of Tiberias in 1841 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 26
1842a: Tiberias and its citadel in a drawing drawn from the north (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Note the similarity of T4 and T5 to their recent state (upper left corner) and the accuracy of the hatch (red square) as drawn by Bartlett Zohar (2017) |
Figure 26 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 27
1842b: Tiberias drawn from the thermal baths. Note the four turrets that erect above the others (probably ruined) and remains of damaged walls (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 27 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 28
1842c: Tiberias from the west. Several turrets seem to be relatively higher than the others and in the western walls large breaches appear (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 28 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 29
1842d: Tiberias view drawn from the citadel of Safed. Note the citadel of Tiberias (P1) (Bartlett in Stebbing, 1847). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 29 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 30
1842e: sketch of Tiberias from the west. Large breaches appear in the western and southern walls of the city (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 30 | Sketch of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 31
1842f: the leaning turret (T21) and the citadel (P1) (Bartlett, 1850). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 31 | Painting of Tiberias in 1842 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 32
1848: Tiberias from the north, probably drawn somewhere on the hill of the citadel (Lynch, 1849). Prominent features:
Zohar (2017) |
Figure 32 | Drawing of Tiberias in 1848 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 33
1849: the road from Safed leading to Tiberias, the citadel and the walls (Spencer, 1850). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 33 | Painting of Tiberias in 1849 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 34
1851: The citadel of Tiberias from the north (Schulz, 1852). One can observe a trail leading from the shore of the lake of Galilee into the city. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 34 | Painting of Tiberias in 1851 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 35
1851-52: Tiberias from the south (Van de Velde, 1857). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 35 | Painting of Tiberias in 1851-52 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 36
1856 (?): the region surrounding the Sea of Galilee (Robinson & Smith, 1856) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 36 | Map of the region in 1856 (?) CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 37
1860: Tiberias from the south (Strauss, 1861). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 37 | Painting of Tiberias in 1860 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 38
1863: Tiberias from the western road leading to the main gate. Note the possible identification of turret T17 (Unknown, 1867). In my opinion the drawing was copied from Munk (1845). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 38 | Drawing of Tiberias in 1863 CE compared to ~2016 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 39
c.1870: a photograph probably taken from the hill of the citadel (Bonfils, 1878?). The northern region was not populated. No minaret of al-Bahri mosque, no dome to al-Zaydani. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 39 | Photo of Tiberias c.1870 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 40
1880: Map of the Sea of Galilee and Tiberias (Lvov, 1880). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 40 | Map of the Sea of Galilee and Tiberias in 1681 CE |
Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 41
1880: Tiberias and its close vicinity (PEF, 1918). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 41 | Map of Tiberias and vicinity 1880 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 42
1885 (?): Tiberias towards the end of the 19th century (Frei, 1885). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 42 | Plan of Tiberias in 1885 (?) | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 43
1900-1920: (ACPD, 1900‐1920). Zohar (2017) |
Figure 43 | Aerial Photo of of Tiberias 1900-1920 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 44
1898-1914: (ACPD, 1898-1914a): large breaches in the western walls, similar to the drawings of Lehoux 1837 (item 16). Note the new dome of al-Zaydani mosque (M1) and that there is no minaret to al-Bahri mosque. Turrets T16-T17 marks the transitions between unharmed and harmed part of the southern wall. A southern road entering the city, probably an expansion of a large breach in the walls, is clearly observed. Zohar (2017) |
Figure 44 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1914 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 45
1898-1914: (ACPD, 1898-1914b) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 45 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1914 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 46
1898-1946: (ACPD, 1898-1946b) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 46 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1946 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 47
1898-1946: (ACPD, 1898-1946a) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 47 | Photo of Tiberias between 1898 and 1946 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 48
. 1931: air photo of Tiberias taken from north of the city (ACPD, 1931a). The W2 part of the walls seems to be compatible with the drawing of Bartlett (item 26) and strengthens the claim that the northern parts of the walls were not affected significantly. Other breaches in the northern walls (E.g., the breach of the northern road to the city) might have been extended only after the event. The red dotted line assists in geo-tagging the location of the photographing camera/airplane (Fig. 3) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 48 | Aerial Photo of Tiberias 1931 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 49
1931: air photo of Tiberias taken south of the city (ACPD, 1931b). Note that some dwellings at the beginning of the 20th century were built on top of existing turrets (e.g., T19 and T20). The red dotted line assists in geo-tagging the location of the photographing camera/airplane (Fig. 3) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 49 | Aerial Photo of Tiberias 1931 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Fig. 50
1938: British map of Survey of Palestine, 1938 (Survey of Palestine, 1938) Zohar (2017) |
Figure 50 | Map of Tiberias in 1938 CE | Zohar (2017) |
Cytryn-Silverman, K, 2015, “Tiberias, from its foundation to the early Islamic period,”
in Galilee in the Late Second Temple and Mishnaic Periods Volume 2: The Archaeological Record from Galilean Cities,
Towns, and Villages, edited by David A. Fiensy and James Riley Strange, Minneapolis, 2015, pp.186-210.
Zohar (2017) A city hit by an earthquake: an HGIS approach to reconstructing the damage in Tiberias (Israel) in 1837
Abbasi, M., 2006. The Tabri family and leadership of the Arab community of Tiberias during late
Ottoman and British Mandate periods. Cathedra, 120, 183–200.
Ambraseys, N.N., 1997. The earthquake of 1 January 1837 in Southern Lebanon and Northern
Israel. Annals of Geophysics, 11 (4), 923–935.
Ambraseys, N.N., 2009. Earthquakes in the Mediterranean and Middle East. A multidisciplinary study
of Seismicity up to 1900. 1st ed. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Ambraseys, N.N. and Barazangi, M., 1989. The 1759 Earthquake in the Bekaa Valley: Implications for
earthquake hazard assessment in the Eastern Mediterranean Region. Journal of Geophysical
Research: Solid Earth, 94 (B4), 4007–4013.
Ambraseys, N.N. and Karcz, I., 1992. The earthquake of 1546 in the Holy Land. Terra Nova, 4 (2),
254–263.
Avi-Yonah, M., 1951. Historical geography of Eretz Israel. Jerusalem: Bialik Institute.
Avi-Yonah, M., 1980. In the days of Rome and Byzantium. Jerusalem: Bialik Institute.
Avissar, O., 1973. The book of Tiberias. Jerusalem: Keter Publishing House Ltd.
Ben-Arieh, Y., 1997. Painting the Holy Land in the nineteenth century. Jerusalem: Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi
Publications.
Ben-Arieh, Y., 2001. The view of Eretz Israel as reflected in biblical painting of the 19th century. In:
R. Aharonson and H. Lavsky, eds. A land reflected in its past. Jerusalem: The Hebrew University
Magnes Press and Yad Izhak Ben-Zvi Press, 255–279.
Ben-Yaakov, M., 2001. The immigration and settlement of North African Jews in nineteenth century
Eretz-Israel. Thesis (PhD). The Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Ben-Zvi, I., 1954. Eretz-Israel under Ottoman rule. Jerusalem: Bialik Institute.
Bender, O., et al., 2005. Using GIS to analyse long-term cultural landscape change in Southern
Germany. Landscape and Urban Planning, 70 (1–2), 111–125.
Bnayahu, M., 1946. Rabbi Yaa’kov Birav - Zimrat Haa’retz. 5th ed. Jerusalem: Mekorot-Eretz Israel.
Buckingham, J.S., 1822. Travels in Palestine through the countries of Bashan and Gilead. London:
Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown.
Burckhardt, L.J., 1822. Travels in Syria and the Holy Land. London: J. Murray.
Calman, S.E., 1837. Description of part of the scene of the late great earthquake in Syria. London:
Lincoln’s-Inn-Fields.
Carne, J., 1826. Letters from the East. London: H. Colburn.
Clarke, E.D., 1810–1823. Travels in various countries of Europe, Asia and Africa. London: Printed for T.
Cadell and W. Davies.
Davie, F.M. and Frumin, M., 2007. Late 18th century Russian Navy maps and the first 3D visualization of the walled city of Beirut. E-Perimetron, 2 (2), 52–65.
de Aveiro, P., 1927. Itinerario da Terra Sancta, e Suas Particula
de Gramb, M.J., 1840. A pilgrimage to Palestine, Egypt, and Syria. London: H. Colburn.
de Thévenot, J., 1971. The travels of Monsieur de Thévenot into the Levant. Newly done out of French.
Farnborough: Gregg.
Gil, M., 1983. Eretz Israel during the first Islamic period. Tel Aviv: Tel Aviv University.
Gregory, I.N. and Ell, P.S., 2007. Historical GIS: technologies, methodologies, and scholarship.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Guerin, V., 1880. Description Geographique, Historique et Archeologique de la Palestine. Paris:
L’Imprimerie nationale.
Hall, J.K. and Cleave, R.L., 1998. The DTM project. Jerusalem: Geological Survey of Israel.
Hasselquist, F., 1766. Voyages and travels in the Levant in the years 1749, 50, 51, 52. London: L. Davis
and C. Reymers.
Heyd, U., 1966. Ottoman firmans on the construction of Tiberias in the 17th century. Tsfunot, 10,
193–210.
Heyd, U., 1969. Dah’r al-Omar. Jerusalem: Rubin Mass Ltd.
Hinzen, G.K., 2013. Support of macroseismic documentation by data from google street view.
Seismological Research Letters, 84, 982–990.
Horne, T.H., 1836. Landscape illustrations of the bible: consisting of views of the most remarkable
places mentioned in the old and new testaments. London: J. Murray.
Hsi-Hsien, W., et al., 2015. Assessment of casualty and economic losses from earthquakes using
semi-empirical model. Procedia Engineering, 123, 599–605. doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2015.10.113
Irby, C.L. and Mangles, J., 1823. Travels in Egypt and Nubia, Syria and Asia Minor during the years
1817 & 1818. London: T. White and Co.
Jacotin, P., 1799. Carte topographique de l’Egypte et de plusieurs parties des pays limitrophes. . .
Construite par M. Jacotin, 1:100000. Paris: Jacotin, P.
Jowett, W., 1826. Christian researches in Syria and the Holy Land in 1823 & 1824 in furtherance of the
objects of the church missionary society. Boston, MA: The Society by L. B. Seeley and J. Hatchard.
Karniel, G. and Enzel, Y., 2006. Dead Sea photographs from the nineteenth century. In: Y. Enzel, A.
Agnon, and M. Stein, eds. New frontiers in Dead Sea paleoenvironmental research. Boulder, CO:
Geological Society of America, 231–240.
Kinglake, A.W., 1848. Eothen, or, Traces of travel brought home from the East. New York, NY: George
P. Putnam.
Knowles, A.K., 2005. Emerging trends in historical GIS. Historical Geography, 33, 7–13.
Knowles, A.K., 2008. Placing history: how maps, spatial data, and GIS are changing historical
scholarship. Redlands, CA: ESRI Press.
Levin, N., Kark, R., and Galilee, E., 2010. Maps and the settlement of southern Palestine, 1799-1948:
an historical/GIS analysis. Journal of Historical Geography, 36, 1–18.
Light, H., 1818. Travels in Egypt, Nubia, Holy Land, Mount Lebanon and Cyprus in the year 1814.
London: Printed for Rodwell and Martin.
Maden, R.R., 1829. Travels in Turkey, Egypt, Nubia and Palestine in 1824, 1825, 1826 and 1827.
London: Henry Colburn.
Madox, J., 1834. Excursions in the Holy Land, Egypt, Nubia, Syria. Including a visit to the unfrequented
district of the Haouran. London: Richard Bentley.
Mariti, G., 1791. Travels through Cyprus, Syria, and Palestine. London: G. J. and J. Robinson.
Mendel, M., 1839. The book of ‘Korot HaI’tim of Yeshuron’ in Eretz Israel. Jerusalem: Anshine M.,
1930.
Nachshon, B., 1980. The siege of Tiberias according to R. Jacob Beirab, Zimrat Haaretz. Cathedra,
14, 55–64.
Nee’man, A., 1837. Arieh Nee’man’s letter from Safed to Amsterdam about the earthquake in Safed.
In: A. Ya’ari, ed. Letters of Eretz Israel. Tel-Aviv: Gazit, 363–367.
Nir, Y., 1985. The beginnings of photography in the Holy Land. Cathedra, 38, 67–80.
Olin, S., 1844. Travels in Egypt, Arabia Petra, and the Holy Land. New York: Harper & Brothers.
Palestine, 1938. Tiberias, 1:5000. Jaffa: Survey of Palestine.
Palestine, 1918. Palestine exploration fund map sheet 4, 1:63,360. Egypt: Survey of Egypt.
Pococke, R., 1745. A description of the east and some other countries. London: Bowyer, W
Pueckler-Muskau, H.L.H.F., 1844. Aus Mehemed Ali’s Reich. Stuttgart: Hallberger.
Richardson, R., 1822. Travels along the Mediterranean and Parts Adjacent: in Company with the Earl
of Belmore, during the Years 1816-17-18. London: Printed for T. Cadell.
Robinson, E. and Smith, E., 1841. Biblical researches in Palestine, Mount Sinai and Arabia Petraea. A
journal of travels in the year 1838. London: J. Murray.
Robinson, E. and Smith, E., 1856. Biblical researches in Palestine, and in the adjacent regions. A
journal of travels in the year 1838 & 1852. London: J. Murray.
Roger, E., 1646. La Terre Saincte, ou, Description Topographique Tres-particuliere des Saincts Lieux &
de la Terre de Promission. Paris: Chez A. Bertier.
Rose, G., 2001. Visual methodologies: an introduction to interpretive visual materials. London: Sage
Publication of London.
Rubin, R., 2006. One city, different views: a comparative study of three pilgrimage maps of
Jerusalem. Journal of Historical Geography, 32, 267–290.
Sagy, A., et al. 2013. Map of ‘Active’ and ‘Potentially Active’ faults that rupture the surface in Israel.
Updates 2013 for Israel standard 413: definitions, comments and clarifications. Jerusalem:
Geological Survey of Israel.
Scholz, J.M.A., 1822. Travels in the countries between Alexandria and Paretonium, the Lebian Desert,
Siwa, Egypt, Palestine, and Syria, in 1821. London: Sir Richard Philips & Co.
Schur, A.A., 2002. Letters from 1833 of ‘Hasidey Carlyne’ in Tiberias. Beit Aharon and Israel Corpus,
17 (4), 247–255.
Schur, N., 1987. Tiberias description in 1831. Ariel, 53–54, 62–66.
Schur, N., 1988. The population of Tiberias during the Ottoman period. Mituv Tveria, 6, 11–15.
Seetzen, M., 1810. A brief account of the countries adjoining the lake of Tiberias, the Jordan and the
Dead Sea. London: Meyler and Son, Abbey-Church-Yard.
Shklov, I., 1837. Israel of Shklov’s Letter from Jerusalem to Amsterdam about the earthquake in
Safed. In: A. Ya’ari, ed. Letters of Eretz Israel. Tel-Aviv: Gazit, 357–363.
Spilsbury, F.B., 1823. Picturesque scenery in the Holy Land and Syria, delineated during the campaigns
of 1799 and 1800. London: Howlett and Brimmer.
Stephens, J.L., 1839. Incidents of travel in Egypt, Arabia Petræa, and the Holy Land. London: W. and
R. Chambers.
Thomson, W.M., 1837. Syria and the Holy Land. Journal of Mr. W. M. Thomson on a visit to Safet
and Tiberias. Missionary Herald, 33 (11), 433–447.
Turner, W., 1820. Journal of a tour in the Levant. London: John Murray.
Volney, C.F., 1788. Travels through Syria and Egypt in the years 1783, 1784, and 1785. 2nd ed.
London: G. J. and J. Robinson.
Wilson, W.R., 1823. Travels in Egypt and the Holy Land. London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and
Brown.
Ya’ari, A., 1976. Journies of Eretz Israel. Ramat Gan: Massada.
Zaslavsky, Y., et al. 2009. Site effect and seismic hazard microzonation across the town of Tiberias.
Lod: The Geophysical Institute of Israel.
Zaslavsky, Y., et al. 2009. Site effect and seismic hazard microzonation across the town of Tiberias.
Lod: The Geophysical Institute of Israel.
Zaslavsky, Y., Shapira, A., and Arzi, A.A., 2000. Amplification effects from earthquakes and ambient
noise in the Dead Sea rift (Israel). Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 20 (1–4), 187–207
Zohar, M., Salamon, A., and Rubin, R., 2013. Damage patterns of past earthquakes in Israel –
preliminary evaluation of historical sources. Jerusalem: Geological Survey of Israel.