Figure 2
Figure 2
Figure 1
Figure 2
Figure 2
Figure 1
Figure 9a
Figure 3
Figure 9a
Figure 3
Figure 2
Figure 3
Figure 1b
Figure 1c
Figure 4
Figure 5
Figure 2
Figure 8
Figure 10
Figure 8
Figure 9
Table 3
Figure 5
Table 3
Figure 6
Figure 7
Figure 11
Figure 12
Figure 13
Table 1
Table 2
Figure 6
Figure 7
Figure 2
Figure 3
Figure 3
Figure 4a
Figure 4b
Figure 4c
The Elat fault system in the southern Arava Valley (Dead Sea rift, Israel) is a complex fault zone, characterized by marginal normal faults and central sinistral strike-slip faults. Paleoseismic evidence shows that the Elat fault system has generated at least 15 earthquakes of magnitudes (M) larger than 6 during the late Pleistocene and the Holocene. At least two branches of the fault zone were tectonically active simultaneously, indicating that the seismic response over a period of 80 k.y. was time and space dependent. Late Pleistocene earthquakes displaced the surface by 1–1.5 m; their magnitudes were between M 6.7 and M 7, and their average recurrence interval was 2.8 ± 0.7 k.y. Movements along the fault system in the Holocene had a higher frequency and a recurrence interval of 1.2 ± 0.3 k.y., but resulted in smaller displacement amounts (0.2–1.3 m) and smaller earthquake magnitudes (M 5.9–M 6.7). Historical records document the last seismic event along the Elat fault zone at ~1000 yr ago. The decrease in tectonic activity with time is inferred from the concentration of offset along the fault segments in the central part of the Elat fault zone and the decreased seismicity in the eastern and western margins. The magnitude range determined for the central zone (M 6.1–M 6.7) was likely not high enough to activate the marginal faults. The average slip rate on the normal faults is 0.2 mm/yr. However, the slip rate has changed through time on different fault segments in the active wide shear zone and between clusters of events related to the same segment. The event- specific slip rates, therefore, have varied from 0.1 to 0.3 mm/yr. The decrease in earthquake magnitudes with time, combined with the observations that the last large event occurred in A.D. 1068 and that no microseismicity has been detected during the past 15 yr, might signal locking of the Elat fault zone. This effect, if true, may result from episodic global reorganization of the system’s mode of strain-energy release, reflected in the configurational entropy of stress states on the fault. These results have significant implications for seismic hazard assessment in the southern Arava Valley, southern Israel, and underscore the possibility that the Elat fault may be a site of major earthquakes in the near future.
One of the most active segments of the Dead Sea rift is located in the Gulf of Elat (Fig. 1). The last severe earthquake (M 7.2) in this area occurred in the Gulf of Elat, 70 km south of the cities of Elat and Aqaba, in autumn 1995. The seismic analysis, including the focal-mechanism solution, showed very clearly that the propagation direction of this earthquake was northward, toward the populated cities of Elat and Aqaba. As a result, a large effort has been directed toward studying the current seismicity and the paleoseismicity of the continental segment of the Elat fault, which emerges from the gulf and heads northward into the southern Arava Valley. In the southern Arava Valley, current seismic and microseismicity measurements show no seismic activity along the segment of the Elat fault from the city of Elat to the Yotvata playa (Shapira, 1997). However, a complex, wide fault zone, with clear, well-preserved surface traces, indicates that large earthquakes have originated along the Elat fault in the past. The ruptures displaced and deformed Holocene and late Pleistocene alluvial-fan surfaces and playa deposits (Garfunkel et al., 1981; Gerson et al., 1993; Zak and Freund, 1966). Paleoseismic analysis and modeling of fault-scarp degradation, including luminescence dating, show that young fault scarps are <2000 yr old (Enzel et al., 1996; Amit et al., 1996). Historical evidence further documents two large events, one in A.D. 1068 and the other in A.D. 1212 (Ambraseys et al., 1994; Amiran, 1994). Motivated by these results, we have conducted a systematic study of the paleoseismicity in the Elat-Aqaba area. Some of the paleoseismic results have previously been published, including partial paleoseismic data and analysis regarding the Elat fault zone. The published studies were focused on several subissues such as
Figure 2
Figure 1
Faults and lineaments were mapped through the use of 1:7000-scale aerial photographs and satellite images. In addition to aerial photographs taken in 1995 and 1996, aerial photographs from the 1950s and 1960s were used in order to avoid loss of information due to intensive human activity, which has damaged large parts of the area in recent years. In addition, information from the 1:50 000 geologic map of Garfunkel (1970) was incorporated. The resulting map is shown in Figure 2.
To characterize the structural pattern of the shallow subsurface fault system, a high- resolution, shallow seismic reflection survey was conducted across the shear zone. Four geophysical lines were shot: one across the marginal area and three across the central area (Fig. 3). The lines followed a previous deep seismic reflection survey at the same locations (Ben Gai et al., 1993). They were shot in a generally east-west orientation by using a conventional common-midpoint (CMP) technique. The spacing between receiver stations on all lines was 2.5 m. The source was applied at every station by using split-spread geometry (Shtivelman et al., 1995). In most cases, a single blow of a hammer was sufficient to generate P and S waves. The data were processed with the PROMAX package. Because only the shallow information was needed, no static corrections were applied to the data (Shtivelman et al., 1998).
Information derived from mapping geomorphic features and from the shallow seismic reflection survey served as the basis for site selection for trenching across morphologic and tectonic elements. Trenches were opened and logged at a 1:20 scale. The trenches are 10–70 m long, up to 5 m deep and 1.5 m wide, with vertical walls. One wall in each trench was selected for mapping. A metric horizontal datum line was established along the trench wall and vertical rod sections were taken to delineate contacts of alluvial and colluvial units and pedogenic horizons. Alluvial and colluvial stratigraphic units were differentiated on the basis of texture, structure, type of boundary, color, degree of cohesion, and pedogenic features (McCalpin, 1996). The soils and paleosols exposed in the sedimentary sequences were described, sampled, and analyzed following procedures of the Soil Survey Staff (1975) and Birkeland (1984).
Two numerical dating methods were applied in this study: Conventional 14C radiometric dating and luminescence dating. Most sediments were dated by using luminescence methods; unless stated otherwise, all ages presented in this study are OSL (optically stimulated luminescence) ages. The gypsic and salic soils and associated sediments in the study sites rarely contain organic material and in general do not contain authigenic CaCO3 that can be dated by 14C. Therefore, only the playa sediments, in which a few charcoal samples were found, were dated by using 14C.
To induce a surface rupture, an earthquake of at least M 6 is needed (Bonilla et al., 1984; Slemmons et al., 1989; Wells and Coppersmith, 1994). This statement implies that the tectonic events that occurred in the study area and that were detected in the trenches were at least of this magnitude. The approach used in this study for estimating paleoearthquake magnitude M is the maximum-displacement (Dmax) method (Bonilla et al., 1984; Wells and Coppersmith, 1994). The equation used for calculations of magnitude M, for normal faults, is M = 6.61 + (0.71 log Dmax). We applied this equation to provide a regression of M on log Dmax for 80 earthquakes in the historical data set (Wells and Coppersmith, 1994). Most of the studied faults are of normal multiple-event type with moderate levels of spatial preservation. On such multiple-event faults, the method based on integration of several displacement samples collected along a surface rupture with globally derived sampling statistics such as proposed by Hemphill-Haley and Weldon (1999) is not applicable. The surface-rupture length method for paleomagnitude estimation is not appropriate either for the study site because erosional obscuring, burial by younger deposits, and fragmentation of the continuous fault line by alluvial-fan incisions make the length measurements uncertain. In relation to the field evidence and the degree of preservation of the faults, our assumption was that the displacements observed in the trenches were maximal, on the basis of the morphologic evidence that led us to excavate the trenches at sites with the largest and clearest apparent offsets along each detected fault line. This assumption might not be true for all the events in a single studied point. But in the light of the problematic correlation between events that occurred simultaneously on an entire surface rupture in combination with dating uncertainties, there is no better way to tackle this issue. As defined by Wells and Coppersmith (1994), the maximum-displacement regression provides only the expected largest slip at a point along a rupture.
A high-resolution seismic reflection survey was conducted at the study site. One line was shot across the alluvial fan of Wadi Shehoret and the Avrona playa sites (Fig. 2, line 1) and three others across the Avrona playa site (Shtivelman et al., 1998) (Fig. 2, lines 2, 3, 4). The interpreted seismic sections reveal that the Elat fault is composed of several distinctive subparallel branches. The subsurface fault pattern is complex, with several converging and diverging north-northeast–trending subparallel fault splays. The fault zone, interpreted as consisting of flower structures, is several hundred meters wide. Its surface expression changes along its trace, alternating between compressional and extensional structures along the central part of the fault zone; normal faults form the fault-zone margins. Generally, the subsurface structures are consistent with the surface expressions of the faults across the alluvial-fan surfaces and the playa (Amit et al., 1999; Shtivelman et al., 1998).
Figure 2The central part of the Elat fault zone is characterized by extensional and compressional structural features, such as grabens and push-up ridges. Flower structures typical of strike-slip faults are clearly defined in the subsurface. Two environments were chosen for paleoseismic analysis. One is a Holocene alluvial fan of Wadi Shehoret that is crossed by a graben structure (Fig. 2, trenches T-18 and T-19). The other, located to the east, is the Avrona playa, across which push-ups, pull-aparts, and normal faults occur (Fig. 2).
The Holocene alluvial fan of Wadi Shehoret (Qa3) is crossed by an asymmetrical graben that trends north. Detailed mapping of the two sides of the faulted alluvial fan shows clearly that the alluvial fan was deformed so that its distal (lower) side is found to be higher than its proximal (upper) side. In addition, the northern and southern margins were dragged below the level of the active channel (Amit et al., 1998). Two trenches were excavated across the graben at two different locations: trench T-18 across the graben’s southern tip (Figs. 8 and 9), and trench T-19 at the stream channel that flows along the northern side of the alluvial fan (Fig. 9).
The sedimentary and pedogenic analyses of the alluvial material composing the Qa3 surface and the dating results of several sedimentary units present a unique scenario. Before the graben formed, the alluvial-fan surface was abandoned at ca. 30 ka for at least 10 k.y., during which a Reg soil developed on its surface (Qa2, unit 3; Figs. 8, 9B). The fan surface was reactivated, resulting in deposition of units 4–6 and burial of the Reg soil (Fig. 8). This alluvial surface was abandoned again at ca. 12 ka, resulting in the present exposed surface Qa3 on which another Reg soil profile developed during the past 12 k.y. (Fig. 8, unit 6). Thus, after the surface was first abandoned, fluvial activity was renewed, and deposition of alluvium continued over the deserted alluvial surface. This sequence of events resulted from the faulting activity during the late Pleistocene in the Shehoret alluvial-fan area, which caused the Pleistocene surfaces to be downfaulted and buried under young Holocene alluvial material. An example of these events is illustrated by the unconformity between the elevated Pleistocene alluvial surface Qa1 and the Holocene alluvial fan Qa3, which buries the downfaulted block in trench T-6 (Fig. 4).
The graben narrows northward and wedges out toward the active stream channel, which flows eastward along the northern edge of the alluvial fan (Fig. 9A). The two sides of the southern side of the graben converge northward into a narrow shear zone, manifested as a vaguely defined lineament crossing the stream bed. Trench T-19 was excavated in the stream bed across the extrapolated continuation of the graben (Fig. 9A). As a result of the deformation of the whole fan (Amit et al., 1998), the sedimentary sequence exposed in this trench is buried under the alluvial cover of the active channel; nevertheless, it is clearly correlative to the sequence exposed in trench T-18 (Fig. 8). This correlation is evident from the existence of the same two paleosols in both trenches and the similarity in their ages. The lower paleosol in trench T-19 was dated at 28.0 ± 2.3 ka (Fig. 9B), whereas the same paleosol in trench T-18 was dated at 30.3 ± 6.8 ka (Fig. 8). On the basis of the degree of soil development, the age of the upper paleosol in trench T-19 (Fig. 9B, unit R2) was estimated at ca. 10 ka, and the upper surface in trench T-18 was dated by OSL at 12.5 ± 3.0 ka (Fig. 8).
The youngest surface ruptures in the southern Arava Valley were detected in the Avrona playa area (Figs. 1 and 2). The playa forms one of several en echelon tectonic basins bound by subparallel left-stepping faults. It is a 10-km-long and 0.5–2-km-wide basin that is crossed diagonally by the north-northeast–trending Elat fault zone. The playa area at present forms a broad, elevated, and elongated ridge. Its relief is composed of low longitudinal subridges (0.5–4 m high and as long as 5 km) and shallow braided channels flowing along and across these ridges. Wadi Avrona and Wadi Raham drain the playa toward the Gulf of Elat through the Elat coastal sabkha. A detailed analysis of the tectonic history—during which the Avrona playa was deformed and changed from a closed basin with an internal-drainage system to an open basin—is presented in Amit et al. (1999). The paleoseismic data are summarized briefly next.
Although various types of primary evidence have been used to infer magnitudes of paleoearthquakes, the length of surface rupture and the maximum displacement on continental fault traces are by far the most commonly used parameters (Bonilla et al., 1984; McCalpin, 1996; Wells and Coppersmith, 1994). In the Elat fault zone, the amounts of displacement during the late Pleistocene were higher, more consistent, and less variable than those occurring during the Holocene. The maximum-displacement method for evaluating paleoearthquake magnitudes shows that during the past 40 k.y., the earthquake magnitudes ranged between M 5.9 and M 7 (Fig. 11; Table 1); they showed a narrow range of M 6.7 to M 7 between 40 and 18 ka and a wider range of M 5.9 to M 6.7 since 18 ka. In addition, a decrease in earthquake magnitudes is evident. The highest-magnitude earthquake occurred between 40 ka and 18 ka. From 18 ka until the present time, smaller-magnitude events were common; the smallest-magnitude events occurred between 10 ka and 2.5 ka.
Recurrence intervals and slip rates are two fundamental descriptors of paleoseismicity, and both are critical components of seismic hazard assessments. In the present study, the recurrence interval involves dating each separate paleoearthquake directly (the geologic method) (McCalpin, 1996; Working Group on California Earthquake Probability, 1995). The purpose of dating almost each paleoearthquake is to bracket the time of faulting during the past 40 000 yr as tightly as possible. The analysis of six faults (seven trenches) and 27 dated tectonic events in the southern Arava Valley revealed that the long-term recurrence interval of large earthquakes in this area (M >6) is 4.4 ± 1.1 k.y. This value differs from the previously proposed value for this area of 1.5 k.y., which was determined on the basis of archaeologically determined seismicity and historical evidence from a time period only since 4 ka (Ben-Menahem, 1991).
Comparative analysis of paleoseismic data from the different branches of the Elat fault zone shows that it consists of subzones in which several faults are active together. Each tectonically active subzone is at least 0.5 km wide. Taking into account the dating uncertainties, at least two neighboring branches of the irregular shear zone were tectonically active simultaneously during several of the total detected earthquakes (Fig. 6, Table 1). However, along one fault line, not all the tectonic events observed in one trench were detected in the other trenches. For example, trenches T-6, T-17, and T-16 are located along the same fault line (Fig. 2), but they differ from each other in the number of detected tectonic events, displacement amount per event, and total displacement amount. However, several events are correlative between these trenches (Table 1). Such changes could be due to high variability in the location of the basement beneath the alluvial fill. Indeed, a trend of deepening of the basement northward was detected by the geophysical survey (Frieslander, 2000). Furthermore, the Holocene has been a time of intense tectonic activity in the central part of the Arava Valley, followed by a decrease in tectonic activity at the valley’s western and eastern margins. This trend is depicted in a time and space diagram (Fig. 13), which shows that with time the large events migrate east toward the central part of the fault zone. However, the inference that most of the earthquakes during the Holocene were not as strong as those during the Pleistocene can be interpreted in two ways (Fig. 11): (1) During the Holocene, the magnitude range determined for the central zone (M 5.9–M 6.7) was likely not high enough to activate the marginal faults, or (2) the evidence for the larger magnitudes during the Pleistocene in the central zone is buried under the thick Holocene alluvial fill in the Avrona playa and cannot be reached and exposed by trenching. Nevertheless, both of these options support the hypothesis that the behavior of the Elat fault zone is time dependent and is characterized by changes in the faulting sequence.
The long record of paleoseismicity along the Elat fault zone shows that this currently nonactive segment of the Dead Sea transform was active in the past, with earthquake magnitudes reaching a maximum value of M 7. Moreover, the present study shows new evidence, which indicates that the earthquake pattern in the southern Arava Valley area has changed over time. By using the maximum-displacement method for estimating paleoearthquake magnitude, we here suggest that during the past 80 k.y., earthquake magnitudes and recurrence intervals have appreciably decreased. The late Pleistocene earthquakes had a magnitude range from M 6.7 to M 7 and a recurrence interval of 2.8 ± 0.7 ka, whereas the Holocene earthquakes had a magnitude range from M 5.9 to M 6.7 and a recurrence interval of 1.2 ± 0.3 ka. Surprisingly, at present, this fault zone has had no instrumentally recorded seismicity, even at microearthquake levels. This finding suggests that the Elat fault zone displays time-dependent seismic behavior. The decrease in earthquake magnitudes with time, combined with the observations that the last large event occurred in A.D. 1068 and that no microseismicity has been detected during the past 15 yr, might signal locking of the Elat fault zone. Such locking may result from episodic global reorganization of the system’s mode of strain-energy release, reflected in the configurational entropy of stress states on the fault. These results have significant implications for seismic hazard assessment in the southern Arava Valley, southern Israel, and underscore the possibility that the Elat fault may be a site of major faulting in the near future.
The Arava Valley section of the Dead Sea Transform (DST) in southern Israel is characterized by the absence of seismic activity in recent times. However, paleoseismic analysis of sediments in the Avrona Playa, a pull-apart basin along the DST, reveals that at least six M > 6 tectonic events have affected the Avrona playa in the last 14,000 yr. The recurrence interval of the events is approximately 2000 yr. Trenched normal faults and push-up ridges in the playa show that the upper 2 m of the deformed sedimentary sequence consists of playa deposits with uniform soil development. The deformed sediments and the soil are typical of basins with an endoreic fluvial system. Based on the limiting age of the sequence and the extent of soil development, faulting in the playa, followed by compression and uplift, occurred in the last 1000 yr. This most recent tectonic event displaced the surface by at least 1 m, consistent with a M > 6.5 earthquake. This earthquake changed the morphology of the Avrona Playa from a closed system with internal drainage to an open basin, resulting in relief inversion. The seismic quiescence in the Arava may indicate a seismic gap in this segment of the DST.
During the 15 years of operation of the Israel Seismic Network, seismic activity along the Dead Sea Transform ( DST) has been dominated by nonuniform spatial distribution. Earthquakes are localized at the three broad pull-apart basins along the Dead Sea Transform: the Gulf of Elat and Dead Sea basins in the south and the Hula basin in the north (Arieh and Rotstein, 1985; Rotstein and Arieh, 1986). The section of the DST between the Gulf of Elat and the Dead Sea, known as the Arava Valley, has been nearly quiescent during the last 15 yr (Shapira and Shamir, 1994; Shapira, 1997). Sporadic activity is associated only with low- magnitude events, which are attributed to motion on branching faults (Shapira, 1997).
The youngest surface ruptures in the southern Arava Valley were detected in the Avrona Playa area (Fig. 1). The playa is situated at the center of the Dead Sea Rift, forming one of several enechelon tectonic basins bounded by subparallel left-stepping faults (Garfunkel et al., 1981; Frieslander, 1995). These basins are filled with fluvial sediments and range in depth from several hundreds of meters to a few kilometers (Ben Gai et al., 1993; Frieslander, 1995).
The geomorphology of the playa area was mapped using 1:7000 scale airphotos and satellite images. In addition to recent airphotos taken in 1995 and 1996, airphotos from the 1950s and 1960s were used to avoid loss of information due to intensive human activity. In addition, information from the 1:50,000 geologic map of Garfunkel (1970) was incorporated. The resulting map, shown in Figure 2, presents the playa morphology, drainage system, faults, inferred faults, and lineaments.
To characterize the structural pattern of the shallow subsurface fault system of the DST and to evaluate its relation to the playa surface morphology, a high-resolution shallow seismic reflection survey was conducted across the playa at three locations 3 to 5 km apart (Fig. 3). These geophysical lines followed a previous deep seismic reflection survey at the same locations (Ben-Gai et al., 1993). The present survey included three P-wave seismic lines (GI-0061, GI-0065, and GI-0074) and one S-wave line (GI-0066), which overlapped line GI-0065 (Fig. 3). The lines were shot in a generally east–west direction using conventional common midpoint technique (Shtivelman et al., 1997).
Information derived from geomorphic mapping and the shallow seismic reflection survey served as the basis for site selection and for trenching across morphological and tectonic elements. Three trenches were opened and logged at a 1:20 scale (Fig. 3). The trenches are 10 to 70 m long, up to 5 m deep, and 1.5 m wide and have vertical walls. Two trenches (T-21 and T-20) were excavated across a fault scarp. A third trench (T-22) was excavated in the easternmost part of the playa, across an elevated ridge composed of playa deposits. One wall in each trench was selected for mapping. Alluvial and colluvial stratigraphic units were differentiated on the basis of texture, structure, type of boundary, color, type of salic horizons, degree of cohesion, and pedogenic features (McCalpin, 1996). The sedimentary sequence was also analyzed in two outcrops: one in the central part of the playa (E-23, Fig. 3) and a second in its southern part (E-24, Fig. 3).
Two dating methods were applied in this study: conventional 14C radiometric dating and luminescence dating. The gypsic and salic soils and the sediments in this extremely arid region only rarely contain organic material and in general do not contain authigenic CaCO3 that can be dated using 14C. Therefore only a few charcoal samples were dated using 14C; most sediments were dated using the luminescence methods. Unless stated otherwise, all ages presented in this study are infrared stimulated luminescence (IRSL) ages.
The seismic history of the Avrona Playa was reconstructed by analyzing the geomorphology of the playa and the fault pattern in the playa sediments.
The Avrona Playa area now forms a broad elongated ridge. Its relief is composed of low longitudinal subridges (0.5–4 m high and up to 5 km long) and shallow braided channels flowing along and across these ridges (Figs. 2 and 3). Nahal Raham flows from the west, cuts the northern edge of the playa, and then flows southward at its eastern edge along a gradient of 0.1–0.15%, forming steep and deep playa margins. The western side of the playa moderately slopes toward the alluvial fans of Nahal Avrona, Shehoret, and Roded. Nahal Avrona, which drains the western margin of the rift, crosses the entire width of the playa and merges into Nahal Raham. The outlet of the Avrona Playa is a narrow channel that flows along the eastern margin of the steep (4–5%) alluvial fan of Nahal Roded, which separates the Avrona Playa from the Elat Sabkha (Fig. 2).
The results and interpretations of the geophysical survey are shown on Figure 4. The three seismic sections show complicated fault patterns identified as several flower structures. Some of the interpreted faults coincide with surface tectonic morphologic elements, such as surface ruptures, lineaments, and small compression or extension structures that permit correlation among the lines. The interpretation revealed that the Avrona Fault is composed of several distinctive subparallel branches. These are labeled A–E in Figure 3. The subsurface fault pattern is complex, with converging and diverging NNE-trending faults extending for several hundred meters.
The field data, laboratory results, and calculated ages of the trench and outcrop samples are listed in Table 1 and shown on Figures 3, 5, and 7. The main source of error for all samples is the scatter in individual single aliquot De determinations, ranging from 4 to 24%, depending on the degree of homogeneity of the sediments. For most samples, errors of less than 5% indicate that they were well bleached at the time of deposition (Clarke, 1994). Sediments collected from the active channel of Nahal Avrona in the Avrona Playa yield residual De values of 0.28 ± 0.09 Gy, equivalent to about 110 yr when using an average annual dose rate of 2500 mGy/a (Table 1). Therefore the ages shown on the figures and in Table 1 are probably overestimated by about 100 yr.
Several high longitudinal subridges composed of sterile playa deposits were trenched and their sedimentary sequences were studied (Fig. 3; fault zone A, trench T-22 and outcrop E-23; and fault zone C, trench T-21). The exposed sedimentary sequence of the easternmost and highest elevated ridge shows alternating fluvial and playa deposits (Fig. 5). A silty–clayey unit occurs at the bottom of the sequence at a depth of 6.5 m from the uppermost ridge surface (Fig. 8, unit 1). It has a weak laminar structure with many non-pedogenic gypsum lenses scattered through the sediment. The age of this unit is 8700 ± 1600 yr. It is overlain by a thick fluvial unit (2–3 m) composed of fine gravel, coarse sand, fine sand, silt, reworked gypsic aggregates, and mud crusts (Fig. 5, unit 2). Cut-and-fill and well-developed cross-bedding structures, which are defined by the reworked gypsic aggregates, indicate that this unit was deposited in wide and shallow channels oriented NW–SE. The middle section of this unit was dated 4100 ± 300 yr. The upper part of the sequence is composed of barren, sterile playa deposits in which a 1.20-m-thick saline soil (Salorthids, Soil Survey Staff, 1975; or Solontchak, Duchaufour, 1977) developed (Fig. 5, unit 3, Fig. 6). Their age is 1400 ± 100 yr. The soil is characterized by in situ pedogenic gypsic nodules, salt efflorescences, and a well-cemented petrosalic horizon at a depth of 1 m (Fig. 5). Reworked playa deposits composed mainly of silt, on which a saline soil has also developed (Fig. 5, unit 6), cap the lower erosion surface. As in unit 3, the soil profile contains large amounts of halite and gypsum scattered throughout; however, it does not have a petrosalic horizon.
Figure 10
The Avrona Basin is now not internally drained, as expected of playas. Usually playas in arid zones occupy topographic lows and serve as receptacles of fine sediments delivered by episodic fluvial or eolian inflows (Shaw and Thomas, 1989; Cooke et al., 1993). At present, the Avrona Playa drains externally and displays no zonation; furthermore, its positive relief contrasts with other playas. Despite its inverted morphology, the Avrona Basin preserved the sedimentary and pedogenic characteristics of an endoreic basin. At all studied sites, the elevated playa deposits contain saline Solonchack soils with well-developed petrosalic horizon. Such saline soils form as a result of complex processes involving salt and water transfer at the groundwater–surface interface (Yaalon, 1961; Dan, 1981; Dan and Yaalon, 1982). This leads to the precipitation of evaporite deposits at the surface and within near-surface deposits on the central and lowest parts of a playa. In this zone, episodic flooding, saline soil formation, and salt accumulation discourage vegetation growth and encourage the formation of sterile areas (Yaalon, 1961; Amiel and Friedman, 1971; Zohary, 1973).
Based on the analysis of trench T-20, the most recent tectonic event was associated with a vertical displacement of 1 m. This event affected the entire playa area, as inferred from the correlation between the soils and sedimentary sequence in trench T-20 and those of the elevated playa remnant in sites T-21, T-22, E-23, and E-24 (Fig. 3). The age of the faulted sedimentary sequence in trench T-20 ranges between 700 and 1500 yr (Table 1 and 3; Fig. 3). Therefore, the sedimentary sequence was uplifted and abandoned after this date. Historical evidence supports this result, for only one damaging earthquake (1212 AD) was reported during the period from 184 BC to 1992 AD (Amiran, 1996). The earliest account states that it was strongest in the region of the ancient city of Aila (Fig. 1), suggesting that its epicenter was in the southern Arava Valley (Ambraseys et al., 1994).
Sedimentologic, pedologic, and morphologic analyses of the Avrona Playa emphasize that Holocene tectonic activity changed the playa area from a closed basin with an internal drainage system to an open basin. The most recent tectonic event resulted in a relief inversion of the Avrona Playa, whereby the topographically lowest part of the playa was inverted to the highest topographic position. This caused reactivation of pressure ridges, pull-apart basins, and fault scarps across the subsiding playa basin. At present, the playa drains toward the Gulf of Elat and the elevated playa deposits, including the soils developed within them, are being eroded.
The Elat fault (a segment of the Dead Sea Transform) runs along the southern Arava valley (part of the Dead Sea Rift, Israel) forming a complex fault zone that displays a time-dependent seismic behaviour. Paleoseismic evidence shows that this fault zone has generated at least 15 earthquakes of magnitude larger than M 6 during the late Pleistocene and the Holocene. However, at present the Elat fault is one of the quietest segments of the Dead Sea Transform, lacking even microseismicity. The last event detected in the southern Arava valley occurred in the Avrona playa and was strong enough to have deformed the playa and to change it from a closed basin with internal drainage into an open basin draining to the south.
The Dead Sea Transform (DST), which is one of the two ridge–trench boundary transforms in the world, separates the African and Arabian plates and connects the spreading centers of the Red Sea with the Bitlis zone, the oblique collisional zone between the Anatolian and Arabian plates (Yeats et al., 1997). Its morphology is well expressed all along its strike, by the Dead Sea Rift (DSR), which is composed of several major linear stretches separated by extensional pull-apart basins, among which the Dead Sea basin is the largest. Geological observations (Quennell, 1956; Garfunkel, 1981; Gardosh et al., 1990; Ginat et al., 1998) as well as plate tectonic models (McKenzie et al., 1970; Joffe and Garfunkel, 1987; DeMets et al., 1994) suggest lateral slip rates of 1 to 20 mm/year. Large earthquakes are known to have occurred along this fault zone, with earthquake magnitudes of M 6–7 over the historical periods (Ambraseys et al., 1994; Amiran et al., 1994). Its seismic activity is characterized by non-uniform spatial distribution of earthquakes. Most of the current seismic activity is localised around the major pull-apart basins: the Gulf of Elat–Aqaba and the Dead Sea basin in the south, and the Sea of Galilee and Hula valley in the north (Arieh and Rotstein, 1985; Rotstein and Arieh, 1986; Shamir, 1996, 1997) (Fig. 1). Between these extensional basins, the DST is characterized by low seismicity (Shapira, 1997). One of the most aseismic segments of the DST is the 40-km-long Elat fault zone that extends from the western margins of the Gulf of Elat in the south to the Yotvata playa in the north (Fig. 1) (Garfunkel, 1970). Continuous seismic monitoring along this segment during the past 15 years shows insignificant to no seismic activity over this time (Shamir, 1997; Shapira, 1997; Shapira and Feldman, 1987). Paleoseismic evidence shows that this presently nonactive segment of the DST is capable of producing large earthquakes, but during the last 80 ka earthquake magnitudes and recurrence intervals have appreciably decreased (Gerson et al., 1993; Amit et al., 1995; Enzel et al., 1994, 1996; Amit et al., 2002). While the late Pleistocene earthquakes range in magnitude from M 6.7 to 7 with recurrence interval of 2.8 ± 0.7 ka, the Holocene earthquakes range in magnitude from M 5.9 to 6.7 and recurrence interval of 1.2 ± 0.3 ky (Amit et al., 1995, 2002; Enzel et al., 1994, 1996). These findings suggest that the Elat fault zone displays a time-dependent seismic behaviour.
Figure 2
Figure 1
The geomorphological and morphostructural features of the Avrona playa area were mapped using 1:7000 airphotos and satellite images (Fig. 2). In addition to recent airphotos taken in 1995 and 1996, airphotos from the 1950s and 1960s were used to obtain information since lost due to intensive human activity.
To characterize the structural pattern of the shallow subsurface fault system of the DST and to evaluate its relation to the playa surface morphology, a high resolution seismic reflection survey was conducted across the Avrona playa at three locations 3 to 5 km apart (GI-0061; GI-0065; GI-0074; Fig. 3). These geophysical lines followed a previous deep seismic reflection survey at the same locations (Ben Gai et al., 1993).
Information derived from geomorphic mapping and from the shallow seismic reflection subsurface data served as a basis for site selection for trenching across morphological elements. Three trenches were opened and logged at a 1:20 scale (Fig. 3). The trenches are 10 to 70 m long, up to 5 m deep and 1.5 m wide. Trench T-20 was excavated across a fault scarp. Trench T-21 was excavated perpendicular to a morphological scarp in the northern part of the playa. Trench T-22 was excavated in the easternmost part of the playa across a structural ridge composed of playa deposits. One wall in each trench was selected for mapping. A metric horizontal datum line was established along the trench wall and vertical rod sections were taken to delineate contacts of alluvial and colluvial units and pedogenic horizons. Two exposures of the sedimentary sequence were also analysed: one at the central part of the playa (E-23) and a second (E-24) at the southern part (Fig. 3). Alluvial and colluvial units were differentiated on the basis of texture, structure, type of boundary, colour, type of salic horizons, degree of cohesion and pedogenic features (McCalpin, 1996). The soils and paleosols exposed in the sedimentary sequences were described, sampled and analysed after the Soil Survey Staff (1975).
Two dating methods were applied in this study: conventional 14C and luminescence dating. The gypsic and salic soils and the sediments in this extremely arid region only rarely contain organic material and in general do not contain authigenic CaCO3 that can be dated by 14C. Therefore, only a few charcoal samples were 14C dated. Most sediments were dated using luminescence methods and thus unless stated otherwise, all ages presented in this study are luminescence ages.
External γ dose rates were measured in the field using a portable calibrated γ scintillator while external α and β dose rates were calculated from the concentrations of the radioelements. Present-day water contents in the sediment range from 1% to 7% (Table 1). However, these values do not reflect water contents throughout the sediments’ burial history. Pedogenic analysis indicates that the water table at the Avrona playa was at the surface several times in the past 10,000 years and that in general the sediments were water-saturated for most of their history. Therefore laboratory experiments were conducted on several sediment types to estimate the saturation values, which are in the range of 20–30%. This range is assumed to represent past water content and ages were calculated using both the current water contents and the laboratory saturation value of 25 ± 5% (Table 1). The ages presented on the trench logs and soil profiles are those calculated using the saturation water contents.
A sediment sample was collected from the present-day streambed of Wadi Avrona, to assess the degree of solar resetting of the IRSL signal in a modern environment. This sample had a low De value of 0.28 ± 0.01 Gy. Age calculations using the average dose rate for the Avrona sediments, ~2400 μGy/year, give 115 years. This residual age implies that the ages presented below could be about 115 years too old.
The Avrona basin is at present externally drained, its relief is inverted and it does not function as a closed basin with an endoreic fluvial system, as expected in playas. A detailed analysis of the tectonic history–during which the Avrona playa was deformed and changed from a closed basin with an internal drainage system to an open basin–is presented in Amit et al. (1999).
The results and interpretations of the geophysical survey are presented in Fig. 4. The three seismic sections show a complex fault pattern identified as a flower structure, with converging and diverging NNE-trending faults extending for several hundred meters.
Figure 3
Figure 4c
Figure 5
Figure 3
Figure 6
Figure 3
Figure 7
The catalogues of historic earthquakes in the Middle East document only two large seismic events in the southern region of the eastern Mediterranean in the last 1500 years: the strong 1068 AD earthquake and the moderate less destructive 1212 AD earthquake (Amiran, 1951; Ben-Menahem, 1981, 1991; Turcotte and Arieh, 1988; Ambraseys et al., 1994; Amiran et al., 1994). According to the earliest account of the 1212 AD earthquake it was strongest in the part of Aila that was by the sea (Ambraseys et al., 1994; Amiran et al., 1994; Avner, 1993), suggesting that it originated on the eastern fault of the Elat depression extending between Aqaba in the north and Nuwieba in the south (Ben Avraham et al., 1979; Ben Avraham, 1985; Abou Karaki et al., 1983). The 1068 earthquake was more damaging and caused the total destruction of the city of Aila and widespread damage throughout the Middle East, resulting in thousands of casualties within a radius of more than 500 km from the Gulf of Elat–Aqaba including north Hijaz, Sinai, Egypt, and the Mediterranean coast (Fig. 8) (Ambraseys et al., 1994). Reports indicate that it was felt all the way to Baghdad (Ambraseys et al., 1994). This earthquake was also associated with a tsunami at several sites along the Mediterranean coast (Willis, 1928; Amiran, 1951; Amiran et al., 1994; Ben-Menahem, 1977, 1981, 1991; Poirier and Taher, 1980; Arieh et al., 1985; Arieh and Feldman, 1985; Turcotte and Arieh, 1988; Ambraseys et al., 1994). Such an event seems more likely to have caused the severe damage and surface rupture of the playa area than the weaker 1212 AD earthquake.
Several considerations indicate that the earthquake that deformed the Avrona playa was of very large magnitude and that it was caused by the Elat fault. Using the maximum displacement parameter (Bonilla et al., 1984; Wells and Coppersmith, 1994), the vertical displacement of 1 m measured for the youngest fault in trench T-20 could have been produced by an earthquake with a magnitude of about M 6.6. A similar displacement was measured in the deformed irrigation canal in the Early Islamic ranch, which is underlain by fault D (Fig. 3) and was also supported by GPR measurements (Basson, 2000). However, this amount of displacement may represent a minimum in the area, as shown by the topographic profiles of the elevated playa ridges. These represent the entire deformation caused by the last earthquake in the southern Arava valley, and show an uplift of 2.5 to 3 m along a deformation belt, which is 10 km long and 0.5–0.2 km wide. Such uplift must correspond to an earthquake with a magnitude higher than M 6.6, which was measured at trench T-20. The surface rupture length cannot be determined in the playa area because of erosional obscuring, burial by younger deposits of the playa and fragmentation of the continuous fault line by incision of the alluvial fan. If the full 50 km length of the fault zone is assumed to have been active during the studied event, the maximum magnitude is expected to be M 7 (Wells and Coppersmith, 1994).
Earthquake magnitudes and their recurrence intervals are two fundamental descriptors of paleoseismicity, and both are critical for seismic hazard assessment. Paleoseismic data from the different branches of the Elat fault zone shows that it consists of sub-zones in which several faults are active together and at least two neighboring branches of the irregular shear zone were tectonically active simultaneously during several of the detected earthquakes (Amit et al., 2002). Such seismic behavior was also detected in the present study area; the 1068 AD earthquake reactivated at least two branches, fault C and fault D crossing an irrigation system dated to the Early Islamic period. Furthermore, the Holocene period is characterized by intense tectonic activity at the central part of the Arava, followed by a decrease in the tectonic activity at the western and eastern margins (Amit et al., 2002). In the Holocene, the faults composing the marginal fault zone of the Elat fault, which is capable of producing high-magnitude earthquakes, seem not to have been active and the faults at the central fault zone produced earthquakes of magnitude M 5.9–6.7 only. Such evidences support the hypothesis that the behavior of the Elat fault zone is time-dependent and is characterized by changes in the faulting sequence with time and space. At present the Avrona playa area, located in the central part of the Elat fault zone, is the active area although this segment of the Dead Sea Rift has been the least seismically active segment during the past 1000 years.
The long record of seismicity along the Elat fault zone in the southern Arava valley provides an opportunity to explore the temporal pattern of earthquakes in the southern part of the Dead Sea Transform. Our main conclusions are:
Colluvial sediments in tectonically active areas are associated with faults, and dating them is important for timing earthquakes and assessing seismic hazards. In hyperarid regions organic matter for radiocarbon is scarce, and the dating method of choice is luminescence. However, colluvial sediments are difficult to date due to the short transport distance that is commonly involved and the resulting incomplete bleaching of the sediment. Single grain and small aliquot measurements of fault-related colluvial sediments may isolate wellbleached grains and provide reliable ages of faulting events.
One of the most active segments of the Dead Sea Transform is located in the hyperarid Gulf of Elat (Fig. 1). The last severe earthquake (M 7.2) in this area occurred in 1995, 70 km south of the cities of Elat and Aqaba. Since then, a large effort has been directed toward studying the current seismicity and the paleoseismicity of the continental segment of the Elat fault, which emerges from the gulf and heads NNE into the southern Arava Valley.
The Holocene alluvial fan of Nahal Shehoret is crossed by an asymmetrical graben that trends NNE. A trench (T18) was excavated across the graben at its southern, wider end (Fig. 1). Samples for luminescence dating were collected from buried terrace surfaces (18-1 to 18-3, 18-13 and 18-16) and from colluvial wedges on the southern wall of the trench (Fig. 2). One set of samples was taken from each colluvial wedge at its heel, close to its contact with the fault plane (18-9, 18-10 and 18-11), and another set was taken from the toes of the wedges, 2 m from the fault plane (18-5 and 18-6). Sample 18-7 is from the center of the lowermost wedge. The samples were collected by drilling into the trench walls and they were placed immediately in light-proof bags. Previous work on these samples has focused on the KF, extracted using routine laboratory procedures (Porat, 2002). The equivalent doses (De) were determined using the SAAD protocol (Duller, 1994) on large aliquots containing 1000–2000 grains, and measurement details were as in Porat et al. (1996).
Quartz from the T-18 samples was extracted from the fraction remaining after heavy liquid separation previously used to isolate the KF. Heavy minerals and any remaining insoluble carbonates were removed by magnetic separation (Porat, 2006) and the non-magnetic fraction etched with 40% HF. Luminescence measurements were carried out on Risø DA-12 TL/OSL readers either at the Geological Survey of Israel (GSI) or at the luminescence research laboratory at the University of Wales, Aberystwyth (UWA). Table 1 gives the field and laboratory dosimetry data for the samples.
The IRSL measurements presented in Amit et al. (2002) were made using standard aliquots which contain approximately 1000–2000 mineral grains. These had revealed some significant scatter in the De values obtained from replicate aliquots of certain samples (Fig. 3a). To investigate this scatter further, two samples were selected, one from the heel (18-10) and one from the toe (18-6) of the third colluvial wedge from the top, and 24 small aliquots were measured, each aliquot containing 150–200 grains. Measurements were at the GSI, and the SAR protocol was followed Wallinga et al. (2000). Preheats of 10 s ranged between 230 and 290 1C and a cut heat of 5 s at 210 1C was used after giving the test dose. The IRSL signal was measured at 50 1C and to reduce buildup of signal background, at the end of each measurement cycle the discs were bleached by IR for 100 s at 280 1C to background level.
In this sedimentary environment, where exposure to daylight may be too short for resetting the IRSL or OSL signals, it is important to identify the most light-sensitive signal. Bleaching experiments were carried out to determine how fast the IRSL signal from KF and the OSL signal from quartz are bleached by sunlight. Ten aliquots each of KF and quartz from two samples were placed in direct sunlight for periods ranging from 2 s to 10 min. IRSL was measured at 50 1C and OSL at 125 1C. Normalization was performed by measuring the natural IRSL and OSL signals for 0.1 and 0.2 s, respectively, prior to bleaching. After bleaching the KF IRSL signal was measured for 5 s, the discs were then preheated for 10 s at 280 1C and the remaining IRSL measured to its full depletion. Quartz OSL signal was measured for 3 s, the discs then preheated for 10 s at 260 1C and the remaining OSL signal measured for a further 130 s.
The samples from the colluvial wedges and three samples from the alluvial terraces were measured using the SAR protocol (Murray and Wintle, 2000). About 5 mg of the purified quartz was deposited on 10 mm diameter aluminum discs using silicone spray as an adhesive. Measurements were carried out either at the GSI using a green-filtered halogen bulb for stimulation or at UWA using blue LED for stimulation, and signal detection was through 7 mm U-340 filters. De values were determined on 12–24 aliquots, preheat temperatures ranged between 180 and 280 1C and the OSL signal was measured at 125 1C. Test dose was ca. 5 Gy and a cut heat of 5 s at 160 1C was used to remove unstable signals. Fig. 4d and e show a typical OSL shine down curve and growth curve for one aliquot. Recycling ratios were within 10% of unity, indicating that any sensitivity change was being appropriately corrected for, and all aliquots had an IR OSL depletion ratio (Duller, 2003) within 10% of unity, suggesting that the signal was dominated by quartz. Laboratory given doses could be recovered within 90–95%.
Single grains from nine samples, six from the colluvial wedges and three from the terraces, were measured. De values were measured for 400–700 grains from each sample at the UWA on a DA-15 Single Grain Risø reader (Duller et al., 1999). The SAR protocol was used to measure the De, with measurement conditions following those of Jacobs et al. (2003). To reduce recuperation and buildup of signal background, at the end of each measurement cycle the samples were heated to 280 1C and the OSL signals were measured at this elevated temperature for 100 s to background level (Murray and Wintle, 2003). Only grains with monotonically growing dose–response curves, recycling ratios within 30% of unity, an IR OSL depletion ratio within 30% of unity (Duller, 2003) and errors on the De of less than 30% were selected. Ages were calculated using the minimum age model of Galbraith et al. (1999), as it is most appropriate for insufficiently bleached sediments (Bailey and Arnold, 2006).
All the De distributions, regardless of sample, mineral or measurement protocol, are skewed, with a substantial tail of older De values (Fig. 3), indicating incomplete bleaching at the time of deposition (Clarke, 1996; Wallinga, 2002). Most samples also have a distinct population of low De values, showing that these samples do contain wellbleached grains. The ages calculated from all the measured De values are given in Table 2. The youngest ages, calculated from the lowest aliquot measured for each sample by the different protocols, are also given.
The reversed age stratigraphy in the colluvial wedges close to the fault plane, first observed in the KF SAAD ages, is also seen in the quartz SAR ages. Even the quartz OSL signal was not bleached rapidly enough over the short transport distance. The dominance of unbleached grains in the wedges’ heels is such that the ages even calculated from the lowest De measurements, which contains the highest proportion of bleached grains, are still in reversed order (Table 2). The slightly longer transport to the wedges’ toes makes some difference, and the youngest ages are close to each other and cluster around 500–2500 years (Table 2).
Source -
Wells and Coppersmith (1994)
Amit et al (2002) suggested using maximum displacement to estimate Magnitude.
| Variable | Input | Units | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| cm. | |||
| cm. | |||
| Variable | Output - not considering a Site Effect | Units | Notes |
| unitless | Moment Magnitude for Avg. Displacement | ||
| unitless | Moment Magnitude for Max. Displacement |
Amit, R., et al. (1999), Relief Inversion in the Avrona Playa as Evidence of Large-Magnitude Historical Earthquakes, Southern Arava Valley, Dead Sea Rift, Quaternary Research 52(1): 76–91
Amit, R., et al. (2002), Paleoseismic evidence for time dependency of seismic response on a fault system in the southern Arava Valley, Dead Sea Rift, Israel, Geological Society of America Bulletin 114(2): 192–206
Porat, N., Duller, G.A.T., Amit, R., Zilberman,
E., and Enzel, Y. (2009). Recent faulting in the
southern Arava, Dead Sea Transform: evidence
from single grain luminescence dating.
Quaternary International 199: 34-44. - redating in Trench T-18
Porat, N., Duller, G.A.T., Amit, R., Zilberman,
E., and Enzel, Y. (2009). Recent faulting in the
southern Arava, Dead Sea Transform: evidence
from single grain luminescence dating.
Quaternary International 199: 34-44. - redating in Trench T-18 - at academia.edu
Zilberman, E., et al. (2005), Surface ruptures induced by the devastating 1068 AD earthquake in the southern Arava Valley, Dead Sea Rift, Israel, Tectonophysics 408(1): 79–99